No. Never! Renesmee (Nessie) would never tham gia the Voluturi in the first place as the came in Breaking Dawn to kill her and her family. If Nessie ever joined the Volturi Bella and Edward would support her decision but they may not be happy about it. Bella and Edward are amazing parents so they would try and understand why Nessie joined them and as long as she doesnt do anything against the Cullen's hoặc their Những người bạn (this means the ones which came as a witness to help Nessie) and stays a "vegetarian" vampire i think both Bella and Edward would forgive her, it may take some time though. Alice would keep an eye out for Nessie (even though it would be a bit fuzzy) and make sure she wont do anything that she will regret in the future.
Edward might take some time, but Jacob would never fogive her. And if she joined because she fell in tình yêu with Alec (Who wouldn't fall for Alec), he might never forgive her.
I think that bella would think its nessie's choice even though she would not accept it she would support reneesmee because she is still they're daughter and probably carlisle and edward would warn aro to take GOOD care of his they're daughter and never to hurt her hoặc else a war shall begin. Alice will predict everyday what happens to the volturi and Rosalie would get annoyed why would bella accept what nessie wanted and probably Jacob(poor jake =[[) will never come back in human form and maybe run till italy to convince nessie to come back and then The volturi will fight with Jacob and Jacob will get some boken Bones and fall backwards and then Nessie will shout ''NOOOO JAKE!!!!'' THEN SHE WILL COME IN FRONT OF JACOB AND FIGHT AGAINST VOLTURI (it would be sooo cool)and Aro and Demetri would force her to come back but she will refuse and then Jane would hurt nessie mentally and Jacob stands up to try protect her but then bec. Jacob came Alice couldnt predict the future so she will see what's happening and she will see Jake AND NESSIE fighting against Volturi ,she would call the cullen family then Aro will accept that nessie to come back to the cullen family because it was illegal to force a child against his family. Carlisle would treat Jacob and Nessie would stay ngày and night staying near Jacob while he's injured... Everyone especially bella and edward would be proud of their... son XD LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại lmao and then LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại after some time (when reneesme is big) they 2 would marry and the volturi would be invited 2 and now Mrs.Black (awwww)would have a half vamp. half werewolf son and LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại Leah clearwater would imprint on him!!!!!!!! lol i have alot of creativity but Yes i think bella would accept the decision reneesme made even though bella didnt want to. but lol...not jacob
posted hơn một năm qua
tình yêu your ideas, bạn should write a fanfic, bạn DO have an imagination
I think not only would Bella forgive her..but would also support her. Nessie was conceived in tình yêu and raised with love. Everyone who comes in touch with her loves her..She may be the hope to help change the old ways of the Volturi...make them once again the "royal family" instead of the punishers that they have become.
to be honest i think yes Bella would forgive Nessie for joining, although i dont think Nessie would- the Voultri wouldn't take kindly to jacob. But back to Bella i mean comeon she nearly died (like proper dying :P )to give birth to her, and they have a bond which means Nessie will always be able to explain her reasons but i also think that Bella would blame herself- think shes done something wrong and tell Nessie she's being stupid to ask for forgiveness when it was she who caused it :P yeah i'll stop rambling now :)
She wouldnt have to, Nessie(Renesmee)would never tham gia the Volturi. Don't bạn know that in Breaking Dawn they try to kill her. Then decide she is no harm and leave. But they kill Irina. But if she did, Bella probably would because Renesmee(Nessie)means so much to her, and she can barely stand not being around her hoặc not holding her. So I would imagine that Bella would forgive her, but wouldnt even have to be in that situation for those reasons.
Bella will always tình yêu Renesmee. I don't think Renesmee would tham gia them anyway, 'cause her gift is not specially useable for the Volturi. I know she's special, but she wouldn't be that stupid either way. Bella would still tình yêu her, and she would probably forgive her. Even though it might be hard.
posted hơn một năm qua
That's actually a pretty close-to-perfect response :)
Bella would definately forgive renesmee because she loves her but she would be irratated and i doubt jacob would allow renesmee to tham gia the volturi ,infact chuông, bell awould probably tham gia the volturi herself if renesmee did ,and then edward would if bella did then alice would if edward did then ,jasper would if alice did ,etc etc well bạn get the idea everyone would end up in the volturi and there would only be one coven pretty pointless
posted hơn một năm qua
WILL PEOPLE PLEASE bình luận ON WHAT I'VE đã đưa ý kiến OH AND VOTE ME ASBEST ANDSWER PLZ PLZ PLZ lolz PLZ
i think Bella would forgive her because she is her mother and Bella cares a lot about her...ya she will be kinda mad, and sad that renesmee joined the volturi but she will always forgive her because she is her daughter and Bella loves her with all her heart.
If Renesmee were to tham gia the Volturi (which I doubt she will), I think Bella would forgive her at some point of time. Bella absolutely loves her daughter; and usually, the bond between mother and child is too strong for any conflict to break off. So yes, if this were to be in the future, Bella would forgive her daughter :)
Any mother would forgive their daughter. But, depending on the situation how thing unfold. If it was against her own will hoặc it was caused bởi a vampire's ability then that would give bella and Edward an over dose of fuel that would make them do anything to get them back. If She ever jions would really be the question.
I doubt that Renesme (Nessie) would tham gia the volturi but if she did im sure Bella and Edward would at first be a little bit angry but then support her desision. The volturi did want to kill Renesme which is why she probably wouldn't want to be a member of the Volturi. If Nessie did then i am sure Bella and Edward would forgive her as they are amizing and loving parents and i am sure that all the cullens (exept Rosalie) would support her. Alice would probably keep an eye on her even though her visions may be a bit fuzzy. Rosalie of course wouldn't stand for this desision as she knows the volturi nearly killed her and tha cullens and Nessie and would probably think for some reason Nessie would be putting them in danger.
Probably not that much. Im currently working on a fanfiction where Renesmee goes against her better judgement, and upon having an affair with Alec (a member of the Volturi), decides to join. Now in my opinion, the rest of the Cullens, and the pack, would probably be pretty pissed about it. I'm sure Bella, Alice, Carlisle, and Esme would support her decision. It would hit Edward pretty hard... Emmett and Rosalie are so close to Nessie... it would really hurt them too. Jasper would try to stay nice about it if Alice was, but otherwise he wouldnt like it either In summary, i think most of them would try to support her decision and do what makes her happy, but it would be very hard for them. Especially Jacob. I imagine he would be devestated if she ever left.
Yes...probably!!! I think that Edward and Bella would go back to bring her home,and they might have to tham gia them selves to get her out. But I don't think that 'nessie' would tham gia with the people who are trying to kill her!!! think about it!
i don't think that Nessie would ever tham gia the Volturi , first!now , if there was a change for that crazy thng to happen then i think that Bella would forgive Nessie because she loves that much!i don't know if Garrett feels that way too!i don't mean to tình yêu nessie as a mother , but how he was going to take it if Nessie joined the one an only coven that was going to kill her and of course after all Carlisle's friends!
NEVER!!! Reneesme would never even think about joining the volturi she is to good for them anyway!! well...... to answer your câu hỏi Bella would probally be mad in the inside but tell her tht she should do whatever she belives is right!!!!!
I dont think she would ever forget her daughter where she went hoặc i f she did joined the volturi, but she would never joined them cause she loves edward to much to even think about doing that to him and the family.
personally i think she would forgive her because Bella loves Renesmee so much that she would respect Renesmee's choice. but i dont think that Renesmee would ever tham gia the volturi because she already fears them
nessie knows who the right leaders are,and who just plane out suck.She'll stay a cullen to the end.which will be a long time.nessie rocks!!go cullens!!!!!!
well maybe renesmee will tham gia the volturi..maybe not. but in my opinion and point of view i think not.Anyways, Bella would forgive and tình yêu renesmee whatever ahe did. Bella absoulutlly LOVES her
I don't think Nessie would ever do that to her parents, and thêm importantly to Jacob. She saw for herself that the Volturi specifically went to Fork to kill her after Irina saw her and reported her to the Volturi. Due to that, the Cullens went to great lengths to scout their closest Những người bạn to be witnesses of Nessie. In the end, almost all stayed to fight the Volturi in order to defend Nessie. It would be very selfish of her to turn her back on her family in order to tham gia the very people that wanted to kill her. Don't bạn agree?
I dont think Renesme would tham gia them mostly bcuz she would stay with her family and Jacob, she knows about the volturi (if she didnt Bella&Edward would tell her). If she did tham gia them i dont think Bella would be relly mad but if Renesme did something wrong like kill someone that was innocent then i am guessing Bella would be relly angry & if Bella was mad she joined them after what they tried to do to her Bella would probably be really angry & maybe never forgive her.
I think that Bella would support Renesmee and forgive her, because after all, Renesmee's a cute little fuzz ball of joy, and no one can possibly be mean to her (except Aro) yeah, but I don't think that Bella would ever visit Nessie, and Renesmee would NOT kill her Mom if she was ordered to.
she probably wouldnt like it to much, but she loves renesmee a lot and even if she did get mad shes known for forgiving people. but i dont think renesmee would because as she grows up she would probably learn that bella is sort of afraid of the voulturi and she wouldnt want to hurt her feelings. and she woul probably get the same feeling towards them from bella saying stuff about them as she is growing up.
Of course Bella would forgive her, she's her mother, but Bella doesn't want that lfe for Renesmee. The family wouldn't see her much. And what about Jacob? I don't see him standing for that life even for his Nesse.
posted hơn một năm qua
Sorry I forgot 2 "I's" one in LIFE and one in NESSIE
ok i believe first of all that renessma would ever do that, but if she did of course bella would forgive her. If bella can forgive edward for leaving her why not forgive precious little nessie
No Way Renesmee Would never Do That And After All Bella's Experiance With The Volturi She Would Never Forgive her! but She Will Still tình yêu Her (After nessies experiance with them too)
I think that it would take bella some time before she forgave renesmee. I mean she has literally forever to think about it. edward might though because he is all for what people decide. it might take him some time though too...just in case she tries to kill them. it would never happen though. the series ended. stephenie!!!!make another book!!!
of course not. I mean... HELLO. Bella, the Cullens, and the ma sói risked their lives for Renesmee. Did they risk their lives for her to tham gia the Volturi? Nope.And,IF Renesmee did join, Bella would be really mad.
Never. Rennesme would never tham gia the voultri because her father(Edward) and mother would never let her do that. If it came to where Nessie would have to come kill her own parents that wouldnt work out to well.
posted hơn một năm qua
bella and edward would support her decision if they really had 2!!!!
Think about it, she is the daughter that her and Edward always thought they couldn't have. They'd still tình yêu her no matter what her life choices. She's her child, Bella couldn't just stop loving her.
Now, some people are saying that Nessie'd never tham gia the Volturi in the first place.
However, think about this situation:
What if the Volturi were able to regain their former glory and power, and then threatened to kill her family and Jacob unless she joined them. I like to think she'd be self-sacrificing enough to give herself up to them if it meant saving the ones she loves. Especially if they had the power to kill Jacob.
It's completely unsupported to just call her a backstabber without any idea of all the possible situations.
I don't think Renesmee would go to the Volturi cause well, what would happen to Jacob? Didn't Jacob imprint on Jacob then if he were seperated hoặc something, something bad would happen to Jacob hoặc Renesmee? But, probably Bella will forgive cause she's a mother and she would probably understand her own daughter's choice of being in the Volturi.
posted hơn một năm qua
LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại u đã đưa ý kiến jacob imprinted on jacob XD
Why would Renesmee ever consider it...they did attempt to exterminate her once before and I think she is very connected to her parents and would honor their wishes....
I believe that Bella wouldn't have to forgive Renesmee because this would never happen. Hate to be stubborn, but if this were to happen I'm sure she'd be able to di chuyển her past it. Renesmee seems to control herself, and just like Bella, she has khó tin self control. I guess they are both new borns, but they have thêm self control than poor struggling Jasper! So, I wouldn't worry about that happening.
i think she would because she is her daoughter right? maybe she might not! but if renesmee did than i would feel bab for jacob because he inprinted on her and i dont think she ever will because she loves jacob!!!
yes because that is her daughter.But bella would have a tim, trái tim attack.Wait can ma cà rồng have tim, trái tim attacks???Then she would go get her.
I think that Bella would forgive Nessie because its her choice not Bella's. and edward would probably convince Bella to be understanding of Nessie's choice because Edward is so understanding himself.!
Of course Bella will 4give renesmee cause she is Bella's daughter, She will be supportive of her decision but Bella and Edward will not be happy about it.
i actually think that bella would totally forgive her i mean, i'm sure she wouldn't like ti one bit but she's her daughter, her little nudger. (but i don't think renesmee would EVER tham gia the volturi in the 1st place, she's too smart for that.)
that would never happen but if it did this is wat i think would happen: bella + edward would be upset but not mad because they tình yêu her so much. they would be mad at the volturi and tell them to take good care of her. Jacob would be crushed so he would go to italy with his pack and kill some of the volturi but not alll of them. alice would see and the cullens would come and kill the rest. then theyed figure out that the only reason nessie joined the volturi was that the vampire with the power to make people closer with other people had made nessie close to the volturi. then since they had killed the volturi the cullens and the ma sói became the new roylty and the non vegitarian ma cà rồng became inspired to be vegitarian.then jake and nessie would get married and have 3 kids. one vampire one chó sói, sói and one half vampire and half wolf. the half would be jenne from the names jake and nessie. the vampire would be ally from the names alice and bella and the half chó sói, sói would be eddy from edward and billy. leah would imprint on eddy and they would get married and have a kid jassem from the names jazz and emmet. jazzem would marry jenne. charlie and sue would get married and have a kid named eseth who would be turned into a vampire bởi ally aand they would get married. then they would all play baseball. then theyed live happily ever after.
posted hơn một năm qua
WHERE IS THE NAME BILLY FROM AND HOW ON EARTH DID U WORK THAT OUT
billy is jacobs dad DUH ,lol i cant beleev uz forgot that ad u call urselfs twilgith những người hâm mộ LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại im noly jokin its billy black jacobs dad
If i should answer straight to the queston- yes of course. Renesmee is her daughter after all! She couldnt hate her. She would accpet her no matter what.
no renesmee hasnt been cast yet ,this is just what one person thinks renesmee would look like and they đã đăng it and its gotten all around the internet ,though is the casting directors see it they may track her down and cast her as renesmee
As insane and creepy as that sounds, I believe she would. Even though it would be upsetting to their entire family most likely, Bella still has her mothering instincts. I do not believe she could stay angry at her daughter, she and Edward's flesh and blood, because of her choices. So as I said, I think she would forgive her. She's a wonderful mom for goodness sakes!
Well... it's 50/50! On one hand the book describes how much Bella loves Nessie and would do anything for her no matter what! It sometimes even says that her tình yêu for nessie is as strong as hers for Edward and maybe more! But then if she went to the volturi it would be heartbreaking and she would deffinetly not like that! She would be against her own mum and family! But then Bella would always welcome someone back and she would want that heartbreak repaired...
i think most of them would try to support her decision and do what makes her happy, but it would be very hard for them. Especially Jacob. I imagine he would be devestated if she ever left.
im not positive, i havent read the last book yet, im still on eclipse, but im pretty sure bella would be ok with it because shes her kid like a mom would tình yêu their kid no matter what, but with edward, of coarse he still loves renesmee, but edward would definetly not let her tham gia the volturi,(you know how edward is "protective")
ps: renesmee is soooo cute<3
posted hơn một năm qua
She would never tham gia the volturie and bella would not be happy about it
I think she might i think she would think it was nessie's choice and after all nessie is her daughter!however i dont think she would like it to much if she did join
First of all i don't think renesmee would do that but for discussions sake i think bella would still tình yêu her...in a way but would always feel betrayed. I wonder how jacob would feel.
I want to say yes I mean it's her daughter right she should tình yêu her no matter what but THE VALTURI! Probably if she pulled a carliel and left after a while. But u should write stefine Meyer a letter
Hell no. but she wouldnt do that cause she loves her family too much. the Volturi would try to get the cullins to join. Besides she's distracted bởi jacob
I think she wouldn't because: The Volturi have hunted both her and Edward who she loves thêm than anything. So, she already HATES the Volturi, if her daughter joined them, it would destroy both her and Edward. Especially if Renesmee ended up hunting them down, even if Bella and the rest of the Cullens survived the attack, after THAT i don't think Bella would forgive Renesmee.
I think she would because: As I said, she loved Renesmee but if after joining the Volturi, Renesmee changed her mind,(not including Renesmee hunting the Cullens) I think Bella would be a bit awkward for a while but eventually she would be able to trust her daughter again.
Yes,of course. The Volturi are not like Strigoi. Aro loves her and will do anything for her to tham gia their clan. He will allow her to continue her vegetarian diet and I think nothing's wrong with punishing the ones who break the law. With her charm, she might persuade Master Aro and give the newborns another chance.
Besides, Bella is her mother, no mother can ever hate her daughter forever and they know that Renesmee is in good hands, with the one she loves, Alec Volturi. The Volturi adores her and would never do her any harm. As long as she is happy, Bella and the rest of the Cullens are happy. Renesmee knows what she wants and what is good and bad. Whatever choice she makes, it would be wise.
i think renesmee would never tham gia the volturi, since they tried to kill her parents and their tình yêu and if they had suceeded she would never have been born and the volturi would never have accepted jacob's tình yêu for her and i think she would never even forgive them, much less tham gia them. with her spirit, i think she'll probably wipe them out of existence
Im sure Bella and Edward would stand bởi Renesmee if she did tham gia the Volturi but without a doubt they wouldn't be happy about it. They tình yêu their daughter too much and as they Volturi did come to kill Renesmee and the rest of the family before hand, why would she want to tham gia them?
So, she may be forgiven over time but it wouldn't be something they would be happy about.
Probably not because she went through all that trouble to protect her and she would just be throwing it away. Bella would not fight her daughter though she would let her go on to what she wants to do.
I don't think Renesmee would ever decide to tham gia the Volturi. She could only tham gia them if she was kidnapped bởi them and is forced to tham gia them. In a situation like this, Bella and Edward, and in fact all of the Cullens would do anything to bring her back trang chủ where she's safe. And of course, we can't forget Jacob and the chó sói, sói pack. Jacob would definitely risk his life to save her and the chó sói, sói pack would be there to help him in the process of saving Nessie.
ok first of all...lots of các câu trả lời for this question! LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại ok anyway first, renessmee would never tham gia the volturi in the first place becuase the Volturi threatened to kill them because Bella has Renesmee i dont think she would betray her family like that after what they tried to do. feel free to leave a comment!
first of all nessie would prob never tham gia cuz in Breaking Dawn they came to kill her family and her but i think bella would support her in it though jacob might get a little mad though
Of course she would.. But seeing who her parents are and the awesome family she comes from... Renesmee would only tham gia if she felt her family was in danger and that was the only way to protect them. Remember Bella left Charlie to protect him from James and Edward left Bella to protect her from him and his family, and Alice left to.. well bạn get the picture.
1. I don't think she will tham gia the Volturi. 2. Even if she did, I think Bella will probably say something like"I'll be happy with whatever bạn choose" hoặc something...
I think that Bella would eventually forgive Renesmee! And it would be Renesmees choise! But i dont think Renesmee would betray her family! They all tình yêu her! And who would wanna drink humon blood? Thats so gross!!!!!!!! I loved all ur answere keep up the good work!!!!!! LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại
I doubt she would even consider it. But if she would for some reason, after they tried killing her, then of course Bella and Edward would support that. She'd probably be very upset about it. But Nessie is her duaghter, it's not like she can hate her own daughter. Same with Edward.
i think she would have to. Even if Renesmee went to them, she's Bella's daughter and Bella can't just walk away from that! That would be very selfish if she didn't forgive her. I don't think Bella could ever do such a thing
well i always thought tht renesmee would be brought up in and understanding family, like, no matter what she chooses in her life the cullens will back her up if it fails type of thing. i think she would be forgiven. if its to protect her family hoặc jacob (eww) she should be forgiven
i don't think Bella hoặc any of the family for that matter would be delighted bởi this fact but i definately think they would forgive her and stand bởi her...they would also do the best to look out for her...but i would really tình yêu to see jacobs reaction to all this..i mean he would probs still tình yêu her and all but i bet he would like try to convince her out of it for her safty but then again maybe not because he always reacts the way renesmee wants him too, that which in my opinion is not what he should do. He should react in whatever way he likes and not according to renesmees feelings...
Of course she would!!!! thats her daughter!!! she would most likely not be very happy about it but really its not like she would ban her from the family...Bellas a bigger person than that. it is a little sad bạn all think so little of her.. :/
SHEMIGHT BUT I THINK THTA IF RENESMEE JIONED THE VOLTURI THAT BELLA AND EDWARD WOULD BE TEMPTED TO tham gia TOO. BUT THEY BETTER NOT BECAUSE THE VOLTURI ARE A** HOLES!!!
it really depends. if she went on her own and didn't even say anything then yes but then again if she was forced to well then yes. she is her daughter so it depends
i don't think she would ever tham gia them with her powers she could possibly look at what happend to her parents in New Moon as a memory of Edwards & realize it's not the place she needs to be. And she wouldn't leave Jake anyways...lol. :)
Well bạn have to think of it as your own oppion and as Bellas oppion. I would forgive Her, if i was Bella i probably wouldnt be very happy and i wouldnt rejoice at her desicion but i would forgive her. I would still tình yêu her, but it doesnt mean that i would talk to her. i think that Bella would Be super super mad, and wouldnt like that very much. SHe would think about how Nesi broke jacobs heart. So thats what i really think that bella would think. she Might forgive her she might not, i mean its Bella who rly ever knows?
She would definitely be disappointed in her daughter. If she stayed there, Bella would always blame her for crossing over to the evil side. But if she came back i'm sure bella would welcome her trang chủ with open arms
Would Bella forgive Renesmee? YES I believe she would! Bella & Edward were prepared to die protecting their beloved child in Eclipse, and a tình yêu that strong will have powerful ties. The bond of tình yêu she has with her family is too strong to break.
However, I don't believe it would happen. Nessie knows the Volturi were there to kill her & annihilate her family. That sort of thing isn't something she's likely to forget (ever) hoặc forgive lightly. She knows the Volturi will come back again one ngày for her family, because Aro cherishes the gifts of so many in their coven. Remember the Volturi have been in existence for over a thousand years, it may take another thousand years but they will be back! She & her lifemate Jacob also know how the Aro fancies the shape-shifters to be their guard chó - she would never allow "her Jake" to be become their dog! He would never be happy with the idea of her joining the Volturi.
I think Bella would support her child in every way possible. I really don't think she will though because she would never do that to Jake hoặc her family. But, if she did happen to yes Bella will forgive her.
ok, why the heck would she tham gia them? but if she did..... eventually. Mothers (evan vampires) care for there daughters. *says in poorly disguised sarcastic sympathetically voice* poor bella "cant live without her"
i just noticed that wen everyone answers, they write like a whole paragraph :L but no, nessie wouldnt do that. she wouldnt be thta stupid. plus, the cullens wouldnt let her
since bạn asked no i dont think she would. becuz if bạn think about it they tried to kill her and edward...so i dont think any of the Cullens(<3) would forgive her for that.
I dnt know. maybe. Renesmee is bells's daughter. if she chooses to tham gia then bella should let her do what she wnts. but i bet bella wouldnt like it very much. she thnks the volturi is a threat.
To forgive means to pardon hoặc excuse. Bella hoặc even Edward would have difficulty in doing so knowing who the Volturi are and what they do. I believe they would both still tình yêu her but may never truly forgive her.
I think she will. Bella can think. She knows her daughter is saver with the Volturi than with them. Also, Bella respect's Renesmee choise nomather wath
No! NOT EVER!!! The voltouri tried to kill bella and her family in Breaking Dawn so if renesmee joined the voltouri then ed and bels might give their daughter the chance! No waht am i thinking!!! Edward and Bella would definatly disagree after what the voltouri had done!!
Even though Renesmee would NEVER tham gia the Volturi (I hope) Bella wouldn't even think about being angry at her. Just think about it, Bella loves her daughter and wants whats best for her so if Renesmee wanted to (obviously Bella would try to stop her) then Bella wouldn't think twice about it.
câu trả lời hay nhất
