Harry Potter Câu Hỏi
do bạn thinkdeathly hollows part 1 was better than the last one? and what did bạn dislike and like about both?
 |
TheFan10 posted hơn một năm qua
|
|
next question »
|
|
|
Harry Potter Các Câu Trả Lời
 |
theonlyexeption said:
yes, i liked DH better, and i liked HBP but loved DH.
JUST SAYING: bạn really should not judge the movie based on its book. IT's supposed to be diffrent! So, a reason for not liking a movie cannot be, the book was better hoặc they forgot my yêu thích part. Because, they didn't froget, they just changed the storyline......
I dont mean to be rude, just that everyone keeps saying that is why they didnt like it, and it is really agrivating. And, just so people do understand, i have read the books...
|
|
 |
lilith84 said:
oh definitely! HBP was an epic fail, so many important stuff from the book missing, the movie didn't make sense. If I didn't read the book, I would have been very confused. Hell, I read the book and I was confused. Instead of a really great story, we got a teenage romance drama. UGH!
DH was good, though there were some stuff that were missing, Kreacher's story for example. And Lily's letter to Sirius (I fear for the Prince's Tale right now). I liked the extra scene, Harry and Hermione's dance, very much, that was a good move.
How can the same director screw up two phim chiếu rạp (because OOTP was horrible as well) and do so much better in the tiếp theo one... maybe somebody actually did Crucio his ass...
|
|
 |
ArcticWolf said:
Yeah, completely. But I liked both.
Hmm, the thing I probably missed the most in Half-Blood Prince was the battle at the end. But I heard somewhere that the reason they excluded it was because it would become too much like the Battle of Hogwarts, and they wanted to make sure the Battle at the end of Deathly Hallows stood out on its own.
But really, I didn't mind both. I've always been the type of person who, as long as it followed the same storyline, didn't really care about the book-to-movie comparisons. Why can't people just enjoy a book for a book and a movie for a movie? I loved the Half-Blood Prince movie, because I didn't let the whole "the book was so much better!" thing get to me. It was a good movie bởi ITSELF, and I liked it. But that's just me, most people don't think the same way I do about this stuff. :/
|
|
