Critical Analysis of Twilight
What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)
Critical Analysis of Twilight Do bạn find Edward's behaviour towards Bella romantic hoặc creepy?
250 fans picked: |
Creepy stalker behaviour
|
||||
I don't find it romantic but don't think it's bad enough to be considered abusive
|
||||
|
Uhhh.... Both?
(added by bbshipper)
|
|||
Romantic
|
||||
|
creepy! i call him edweirdo!
(added by alice-hale-)
|
|
Make your pick! | next poll >> |
My new way of explaining my opinion to Twi-hards (I actually convinced one Edward was abusive with this argument *proud*) is to ask 'would you still find it romantic if an ugly guy did it?' as Twi-hards seem willing to excuse anything Edward does based on his looks.
Thing is, if something's ok, if it's romantic, it is no matter who does it. Like an invite to a candlelit dinner. That's a romantic notion whether it's from a hottie or an obese spotty cross eyed guy. The idea is still romantic even if the advances of the ugly guy are rejected/unwelcome. But if a fat, cross eyed, spotty guy sat outside your window watching you sleep for months would you find it romantic? no, you'd freak out and call the cops. But it is when Edward does it? And if Edward was described in the books looking more like Quasimodo than Robert Pattison would there be as many people willing to rabidly defend his behaviour as romantic?
Well, looks aren't what decide if something like that is ok, and if the only thing keeping you from considering someone a stalker is thinking 'they're soooo hot' then really, how they're acting is creepy isn't it?
I don't care how hot the guy is. Watching someone sleep is not really something a mentally heathly person does.....just saying.
it doesnt mater to me about RPatz
im Team Jacob teehee
Just my opinion, not meant to insult yours
For a list of the 'abuse signs' Edward fits here's an article written by Cinders:
link
He took the engines out of her car so she couldnt see Jacob
Told his sister to "kidnap" her she she wong see Jacob
Forced her to go to prom
Enough said.
and I do think the *creepy* things are like that because he's a vampire!
and IT DOES MAKES A DIFFERENCE.. I mean, do you hate old vampires because they kill people?? NO YOU DON'T.. and why is that? because they are vampires!........ XD
and being completely serious about this.. in the whole story Edward never did ANYTHING an abusive boyfriend would do..
on the contrary, he always protected her and was constantly trying to save her..
oh and (still talking about VAMPIRES IN THE STORY right? 'cause in real life a guy watching me from my window when I sleep.. I don't care if he is matthew mcconaughey I'll still shoot him)
yes, if Edward was an ugly guy, a cute guy, a stupid guy.. I still think it is romantic.. he loves her, and the way he protects her from anything for me is just.. lovely ^^
Also, to me part of love is wanting someone to evolve and reach their full potentail. You love them so you want them to achieve and be all they can. With Edward I always got the impression he wanted Bella to never evolve or acheive, just to stay exactly where she was both literally and emotionally. You can't protect someone from the whole world, it stops them living to their fullest.
You're entitled to your opinion, I'm not trying to undermine what you said or change your mind, just responding with how I feel on the subject :)
Anyway, some of his behavious is creepy, that's undeniable. Watching people sleep without their knowledge or permission, following your girlfriend round after she 'escaped' from your sister who was 'keeping her hostage'... All very creepy. But he is also romantic at times too. So it would depend on what part of Edward's behaviour we're talking about. :)
Not to mention hes too OBSESSED about Bella!!
TEAM EDWARD 4 LIFEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1) He watches her SLEEP. What kind of sane, healthy person watches their girlfriend SLEEP?
2) He watches her everywhere she goes, like a hovering ghost or something, which gets really annoying.
3) It's only romantic because he's all "Sparkly Vampire" and Bella is all like, "Oh Edward! I love you so! I don't care what my friends say, or what my Dad says! I love you! But I love Jacob! But I love you as well!"
đăng nhập hoặc tham gia fanpop để đăng bình luận của bạn