How is it possible that when bella slaps Paul in the new moon movie and nothing happens to her hand but in the eclipse book, when she punches Jacob her hand breaks?

That is a great question, and yeah, it probably was a little mix up in the script.
Unless she didn't hit him hard enough........?
;P

She "punches" Jacob with a closed fist..very easy to break bones...she "slaps" Paul with an open hand...very hard to break Bones when the hand is open... :) Go Bella!

huh... I haven't thought about it... I really don't know, it's probably a mistake in the script hoặc while directing... hoặc it's just because they wanted to emphasise the punch-scene thêm than the slap-scene... it's a great câu hỏi though... you're very observant...!!!

omg wow that is a great freakin câu hỏi i would have never hought of it if bạn never đã đưa ý kiến anything... yea that is pretty stupid.... i hope they have an explanation for this.... good eye ;)

well in eclipse she hits him in the chest and stomach area which i guess is harder then a cheek.
it's really confusing ,but that is my best guess.

Good point there.
But, yea, maybe she didn't hit him that hard.

well when she punched him she probably punched him with her thumb inside her hand and the force of the cú đấm oushed back on her fingers so hard that it broke her hand. i know its confusing but yea.....i asked the same câu hỏi too.

Thats what i as saying too!
But i'm guessing that she Slapped Paul a little
bit, But full on Punched Jacob.

She probably didn't hit Paul as hard as she did Jacob