The Man in the High Castle: TV series versus book 

More Thoughts about The Man in the High Castle: Upping the Metaphysical Ante

The Man in the High Castle here, and the rest of the series here, but refrained as much as possible from comparing the extraordinary television series to the extraordinary novel, and from putting any spoilers in the review.  But there are two very significant differences between the book and the TV series, which can\'t be discussed without giving away some important events in the television series, so I\'ll do that here with a spoiler warning.   Read on, if you\'re interested, and have seen the television series and read the novel, or know neither or just one, and are interested anyway.

In the book, the man in the high castle is the author of the book within the book, The Grasshopper Lies Heavy.   In the television series, the man in the high castle is not explicitly named, but is presumably Hitler.   He\'s shown living or at work in a high castle, with newsreels of the alternate histories on his shelf.  The man in the high castle was earlier identified as someone who collects the newsreels - that\'s why the resistance and the Nazis want them.  But this still leaves open the central question of: who created in the newsreels in the television series?   As one of the characters in the resistance remarks, why would the person who is collecting the newsreels be the same person who created them?   Perhaps Hitler has some as yet unfathomable agenda - which, at this point, as the first season ends, is just to know the alternate histories that the newsreels are revealing.

The difference between a book within a book in the novel and newsreels in the television series as media of alternate history lead to another difference between the Philip K. Dick novel and the Frank Spotnitz television series that in many ways is the most profound difference of all: When Juliana and Frank see Joe as a Nazi killing Frank in the newsreel at the end of the 9th episode, there\'s no doubt that the people in the newsreel are indeed Frank and Joe.  The characters can\'t make much sense of this, but we the viewers understand that we\'re literally seeing either an alternate history or the future.   This literal look at an alternate history is much more powerful, metaphysically, than anything that can be described in a secret book.   Writing, is, after all, a description of people and events.   In contrast, visual media such as newsreels are literal recordings of those people and events.  Of course they can be distorted and manipulated, but at their very basis, literal images traffic with the truth in a way that written words cannot.  (See any of my books about media theory for more.)

Newsreels were of course around when Dick published the novel in 1962, but he chose, for whatever reason, to go with the book within the book as the alternate history medium (whether he didn\'t think of newsreels, or rejected them as a vehicle for some reason, we\'ll never know).   But brilliant of Spotnitz to make them the vehicle of the television series - starting with the newsreel at the beginning of every episode - and open up so many new and compelling possibilities.

What if the Soviet Union had survived into the 21st century 

Labels: alternate history, Frank Spotnitz, Philip K. Dick, The Man in the High Caste

The Chronology Protection Case movie, with new extended ending

With The Closer now ending its Winter 2011 season, and only six episodes left to go this coming Summer of 2012, it seems a good time to as...

With The Closer ending its Summer 2011 run, and only a few episodes left for Brenda Leigh Johnson in the Winter finale, the question looms...

=What's Newer than New New Media= October 24, 2015: 2 and 1/2 minutes about Uber Which new social media are gaining traction aft...

Who is Ben Hargrove?  He's the nom de plume - fictitious name - which Ken Cosgrove uses when his science fiction and fantasy stories ar...

Having delved into the meta-realms of unreal science fiction with Ben Hargove some five episodes ago, Mad Men 5.10 continues the enjoyabl...

Well, we got the apparent shock of the series on Game of Thrones 1.9 last night - after following the advice of the eunuch and others to c...

A Postcard from Isaac Asimov to Me - From 1979

I posted my blog about Nobel Laureate Paul Krugman and Isaac Asimov in several other venues last night, including the Daily Kos , where a ...

An excellent, nerve-wracking, powerhouse Season 2 finale of The Following tonight, in which, against all odds - almost no one significant ...

Hey, you've all seen that Citibank commercial, with the woman climbing to the top of an awesome rock formation, and another woman belti...

I caught the first three episodes of the new season of Dexter last night - Season 7, set to premiere on Showtime September 30 - courtesy o...

The Plot to Save Socrates on 10 Perfect Summer Reads Authored by NYU Alums

my Internet Science Fiction Data Base bibliography

This blog quoted in New York Times & Los Angeles Times & Boston Globe & The Atlantic!

TWICE UPON A RHYME on iTunes and Amazon ... SPUN DREAMS on iTunes and Amazon ...

ICYMI: recent interviews with Paul Levinson in Barren Island Books ... The Morton Report ... SpecMuse ... The Cult of Me ... Patrick Satters blog ... Hungry Writer ... Kathleen Valentine\'s blog ... Take the Plunge ... Writer\'s Bloc ... Noahkmullette-gillman blog ... Book Goodies ... johnmac Radio Show

Shelfari: Book reviews on your book blog

Cellphone: The Story of the World\'s Most Mobile Medium and How... by Paul Levinson

Digital McLuhan #16 on Robert Anton Wilson\'s recommended book list ...

Sopranos Conference at Fordham Universty, May 22-25, 2008

Enjoy Levinson\'s Field Guide to Republican Tics

EllisLanding ... wide variety of books in excellent condition at low prices

Paul Levinson, PhD, is Professor of Communication & Media Studies at Fordham University in New York City.  His 8 nonfiction books, including The Soft Edge (1997), Digital McLuhan (1999), Realspace (2003),  Cellphone (2004), and New New Media (2009, 2nd edition 2012), have been the subject of major articles in the New York Times, Wired, the Christian Science Monitor, and have been translated into 12 languages. His science fiction novels include The Silk Code (1999, ebook 2012), Borrowed Tides (2001), TheConsciousness Plague (2002, 2013), The Pixel Eye (2003), The Plot To SaveSocrates (2006, ebook 2012), and Unburning Alexandria (2013).  His short stories have been nominated for Nebula, Hugo, Edgar, and Sturgeon Awards.  Paul Levinson appears on "The O'Reilly Factor" (Fox News), "The CBS Evening News,"  “NewsHour with Jim Lehrer” (PBS),  “Nightline” (ABC), NPR, and numerous national and international TV and radio programs. His 1972 album, Twice Upon a Rhyme, was re-issued in 2009 (CD) and 2010 (remastered vinyl). He reviews the best of television in his InfiniteRegress.tv blog, and was listed in The Chronicle of Higher Education’s “Top 10 Academic Twitterers” in 2009.

Chronicle of Higher Education puts Paul Levinson in Top 10 (#7) of Academic "High Flyers" on Twitter ... Online University Data puts PL in "Top 50 Online University Professors on Twitter Worth Following"...

Dear Paul, I just dreamed of airships flying between raindrops. I just returned from 2042 CE, where I sold my hardcover copy of The Plot to Save Socrates for seventy million Neo-Euros, because it had your response to this e-mail from way back in 2007 scotch-taped onto the inside of the cover. A Paul Levinson collector paid top Neo-Euro, because of the authentic archaic e-mail printout from you. It turns out that not many of your e-mails from before your tenure as CEO of HBO/Cinemax and terms as United Nations Secretary General will survive that far into the future. So, please respond to this e-mail, to help found my great-grandchildren\'s fortune. My Will will stipulate that they must share with your great grandchidren. Thanks! Tom

President, Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, 1998-2001

I’m proud to be on the May 8 page of this calendar, with the following quote:

"What begins as a seemingly innocent campaign against indecency … always segues in short order into political censorship."

YouTube one-on-one with Bill O\'Reilly, Patrick Buchanan, Jesse Ventura, James Cameron, more

Educated Tastes food, drink, restaurants, recipes, groceries

Reverbnation Twice Upon a Rhyme and Spun Dreams albums

More Thoughts about The Man in the High Castle: Up...

Hillary Clinton Strong in Second Democratic 2016 P...

Fourth GOP Presidential Debate: Rand Paul Scores

The Good Wife 7.6: Hillary, Trump, and Alicia

"the only people who have proof of their sanity are those who have been discharged from mental institutions"— Marshall McLuhan

The Factor about the private lives of news anchors

winner Locus Award for Best 1st Science Fiction Novel, 2000

"Forensic detective Phil D’Amato one of my favorite characters" -Connie Willis

"A superb and often amusing account of one of the greatest revolutions in human history" --Arthur C. Clarke

James Harris covers my "Looking for Sunsets (in the Early Morning)"

100 rare + unreleased tracks were on sale April 18-21, 2011. All proceeds went to help Japan! Thanks for your generosity! Tracks included Tori Amos, Sara Bareilles, Josh Ritter ... and Paul Levinson singing "Sunshine\'s Mine"!

Twice Upon a Rhyme reviewed in Jan-Feb 2011 Shindig Magazine

radio stations that have played tracks from

Twice Upon a Rhyme ... JackMix.FM ... RockOn365 ... Garage Lombus ... Way Off the Grid Radio ... BeautyRadio.com ... mjc Radio ... Progulus Radio ... fatBuzz ... The Rock Doctor ... Radio BGC ... Swan Fungus ... Gratitude Radio ... Travelling Underground ... Real Hit Radio ... More than Music and Memories ... Boston Internet Radio ... Memory Lane Radio with BIG BOB ... Outside the Dial ... Family Dog Radio ... Golden String Radio ... Positively Charged ... R@dio Dimension ... My Retro Radio ... Plastic Tales from the Marshmallow Dimension, WNYU, 89.1 FM, New York City ... Pete Fornatale\'s Mixed Bag, WFUV, 90.7 FM, New York City ...Click and get lucky!

science fiction magazines for sale: Analog, Fantasy and Science Fiction, Locus

Paul Levinson appears on "The O\'Reilly Factor" (Fox News), "The CBS Evening News," "Nightline" (ABC), the "NewsHour with Jim Lehrer" (PBS), "The Dylan Ratigan Show" (MSNBC) and frequently on NPR and all-news radio...