Cool another game. Good idea jodith :D

Dean putting itching powder in Sam's underwear lol (Sam in a towel ;)

Cas eating burgers
or
Dean eating burgers?

Dean eating burgers (just classic!)

Sam's puppy-eyed look
or
Castiel's puppy-eyed look?

Cas makes puppy eyes? (Sorry, I'm still not that far into the show yet.)
anyway, Sam's puppy eyes (another classic, right?)

Ruby's knife
or
The Colt?

#thx joose32 ..
##ofc.the colt!!!! just awesome..
###this one is hard i guess:

sam's deal with crossroad demon to save dean
or
dean's deal with crossroads demon to save sam

deans's deal with crossroads demon to save sam :D

Michael
or
Gabriel

Gabriel 4 sure..

Team Free Will
or
Team Winchester?

Awesome game XD
Hmmmm.... Team Free Will - it has Gabriel in it too (technically) XD
OK:
Demon Dean
or
Demon Sam

Demon Dean xD (totally HOT)

Luc. in sam's Body.
or
Micheal in Adam's Body.

Lu in Sam's body (though I still like Lu in Nick's body best)

"I bet a fiddle of gold against you soul because I think I'm better than you"
or
"Such anger... young Skywalker"

"I bet a fiddle of gold against your soul because I think I'm better than you" - just cos I love that song! and the way he sorta says the last words in a sing song voice creeps me out!

The Trickster
or
Gabriel
(attitude wise)

^^^I love that song too!

Gabriel, any day of the week!

Castiel, the Angel
OR
Castiel, the Human

Castiel, the Human- he was more loveable when he was powerless (does that sound sadistic to you?), and so cute when clueless!

Sam as Meg
OR
Sam as Lucifer

ok..that one is hard i guess""JUST SAM?? "lol"..cuz i hate them both but if i had to choose i'll go with..sam as Meg.he was smartass but sam as Luc. is a Jackass..

Dean with lisa
or
Dean with carmen

Dean with Lisa

lol, jodith- he was smartass but sam as Luc. is a jackass...

Adam as a ghoul
OR
Adam as Michael

Oh God.... thats mean.... Maybe as Michael, I mean he was a bit of a dick as Michael, but he was pure evil as the ghoul.

Anna killing Uriel
or
Lucifer killing Gabriel
(More dramatic)

Lucifer killing Gabriel i still cant believe he did it.
damn u Luc...

Dean living a NORMAL life?!!
or
Dean keep Going as a Hunter?!> totally this one ^^

Dean keep going as a hunter (totally for me, too!!!)

Dean's smile
OR
Dean's eyes

(I feel evil today!)

^ That is so evil xD Ummmm Dean's Eyes. So Prettyful :D

Sam's Smile
or
Sam's Puppy Eyes

Sam's smile (even though we don't get to see enough of it)

Lisa

OR

Jo

Jo

Cas' smile
OR
Cas' voice

Ummmm Hard Choice but Cas' Voice (haha that unintentionally rhymed xD)

Nick as Nick
or
Nick as Lucifer

Uh.... we didn't see enough of Nick as Nick really, so I will have to go with Nick as Lucy - just cos he's is strangely, satanically likable!

I'm gonna join with the character look options too lol

Gabriel's Mischevious Look
or
Gabriels Serious Look

I agree, I loved Lucifer, he was awesome..

who was you fave horseman? (DEATH WAS SOOO GOOD!)

death
or
pestilence

DEATH. Pestilence was icky xD
& Death's theme song was epicness in a bottle :D

Young John
or
Oldish John?

In answer to doc (cuz no one else did), Gabe's mischievous look.
In answer to GBE, young John. Matt Cohen is CUTE!!!

Matt Cohen
OR
Amy Gubernick
(based on acting talent)

Probas Amy Gumernick, but Matt Cohen is also awesome!

Present Cas
or
Future Cas

Present Cas...coz he's relaxing a bit but it's still restrained making it hilarious
...oohh crap i have to think of one

"Son of a Bitch"
or
"Dude"

p.s. this is fun!

Haha I say Dude more so "Dude"
Though "Son of a Bitch" is also part of my vocabulary xD

Ronald (Mandroid Dude)
or
Andy

Andy, I love him!

YED or Lu

YED!!!!!!!!!!!!!! when it comes to Demon/badass evil guys im a total YED G!RL i love him..

tissa
or
lisa

Lisa's reaction to the whole changling thing in "The Kids Are Alright" was sooo cool and calm. Most chicks woulda freaked, so I have to go with her.Besides that, she's tough enough to put Dean in his place ;)

Dean teaching Sam how to fix the Impala
or
The brothers having a Christmas moment (at the end of A Very Supernatural Christmas)

Dean outting Sam in Playthings *dolls*
or
Dean outting Sam in AVery Supernatural Christmas *wreaths*(lol)

wow two things... ok first one is Brothers having a x'mas moment

second the dolls XD
"Big time..."

Out of the two nicknames I have seen on the internet for our boys:
Deany-bear
or
Sammich

Awww they're both cute but I'm gonna go with 'Sammich' because that's how my nephew used to say sandwich when he was 3 :D

Who/what would you rather be attacked by?
Shtriga (sucks your life force)
or
Toothfairy (pulls all your teeth out but... leaves a quarter for each tooth pulled)

Hmmm... difficult choice xD

Oh God.... I think I might have to go with.... Oh dear..... probably.... uh.... Shtriga? Cos I hate the dentist hehe (remind myself of Alec from DA there.... "Was it the teeth thing? Cos you know I hate the dentist." LOL

Ok. Next:

Watching Richard Speight Jr play guitar in his band
or
Watching Misha Collins playing drums in, was it, ER?

To answer the earlier question..I like "Padackles" *lol*

And I haven't seen these two in action, but since I like to watch Misha do anything, I'm gonna pick him anyway.

Who's screw up was worse....
Dean breaking the first seal
or
Sam killing Lilith

Sammich, lol!!!

Sam killing Lilith, cuz he never should have trusted Ruby in the first place.

Dean killing the vampire in Bloodlust
OR
Sam killing Gordon in Fresh Blood

(I might have the ep names backwards, can't keep the vamp eps straight)

Sam killing Gordon of course! I didn't like Gordon because of what he did to the boys.

Jack (The Rugaru) eating raw meat in Metamorphosis
or
Cas eating raw meat in My Bloody Valentine

Will have to say Cas cos as gross as it was, he makes anything look sexy ;)

Dean eating pie
or
Sam shaking his salad shake

Sam shaking his salad shake :) I just watched that again this morning *lol*

Dean's paranoia in Yellow Fever
or
Dean's psychosis in Sam Interuppted

Dean's paranoia in Yellow Fever xD

Getting hit in the head with the remote Dean threw
or
Getting hit in the head by Chucks plunger

Remote!!!

Drunk Dean
or
Drunk Sam XD

Drunk Sam xD

Greasy pork sandwich served in a dirty ashtray
or
Funny tasting taco's

Funny tasting taco's, I love that episode poor Sammy and poor Dean lol :)

Cas as a human
or
Cas as an angel

Cas as an angel... all that power is so hot! And the trenchcoat. XD

Sam with short hair
or
SAm with long hair

Sammy with short hair. Awww his bangs were adorable :D

Dean's I wuv hugs t-shirt
or
Dean's leather jacket

Dean's leather jacket. O_________O
I bet it smells like him....Yeah. XD

Dean bleeding because of YED in John's body
or
Dean bleeding because of Samifer's beat down in Swan Song?

Er... the beat down. Cuz he got better real soon.

Dean's jacket
or
Sam's jacket

Dean's jacket all the way!!!

Gabriel's idea of romance - flower, candlelight and champagne
or
Castiel's idea of romance - ORGYS ALL ROUND!

gabriel ! you're sweet. i like sweet. B-)

winter hellatus
or
summer hellatus

Ummm since it's winter here I'll say summer hellatus xD

Jesse cooking soup on a stove
or
Dean cooking a ham with a joy buzzer