What scene do bạn think this *almost* Kiss is from?

I think that it's maybe the part in New Moon where Edward tells Bella that he's leaving without her. They both look pained?

I believe it's from the beginning, on her birthday, They're either greeting each other hello at school hoặc saying bye.

I think it's the too urgent Kiss at her birthday. After the incident with Jasper, hoa hồng and crystal vases. When Edward brings her home, she asks him to not ignore her birthday and Kiss her :D

There are several options to consider, all I think which have already been addressed here. But oh well.

1) It is something the Director, Chris Weitz, has added in that is not seen in the book. Possibly from the break up scene, hoặc the after the birthday. We know it is not from the reunion as we have seen that scene.

2) It is from before the break up, such as before the birthday hoặc something.

3) It is at the end of the movie, like the one they did at the prom.

well the movie sequel new moon is going to be different from the book in the edward department. see what they're going to do is make it to where bella not only hears him but sees him too-so this must be a scene where she has an edward hallucination hoặc it could be that nightmare that she always had but changing it up a bit. that's my guess.

I think it's the scene were it's bella's birthday and they are at school.

its twilight..i cant remember what scene but its from the first movie