I actually thought tonights episode was one of the better ones so far this season. however, certain storylines are still repetitive... ESPECIALLY with Nathan and his basketball. Ofcourse something once again got in the way of him living his "dream". and surprise surprise, next week he'll get another chance at playing ball again... same old, same old.

But I thought the Brooke stuff tonight was just heartbreaking. It felt similar to the old OTH storylines. It was deep, it had meaning, heart, and purpose. And It wasn't the same old story that we've seen a million times before. You could really tell how hurt she was, and I loved how Julian was there for her. I think us finding out that Brooke can't have kids is the first thing to happen this season that actually had a purpose, and wasn't repetitive.

overall, this was one of the few episodes this season that actually held my attention

I think it's a 4.
It was a good episode, but def not my favorite of the season. If this was season 5 or 6, where almost the episodes were crappy, i would give it a 5.

It was a 4!

I thought it was one of the best so far.

In my opinion it was a 4. I really loved the Brooke stuff, though it was heartbreaking but I feel the Nathan stuff is repetitive.

OTH was awesome this week! My favorite storyline was with Brooke, it was the saddest thing ever and that final scene with her and Julian sleeping together was so cute.

The Nathan/Clay storyline is good,but I'm having a hard time choosing who's side I'm on, both have valid points. As for the Haley/Quinn fight I'm defiantly on team Haley, I though Quinn was annoying this episode.

The Millie/Mouth scene was also really sad, where she lied to him about the coke. I do like this storyline for them though.

This episode was really good and kept me wanting more. Oh, and Dan is freaking awesome!

Really good one!