Madoka isn't a jerk.

Yeah Madoka's really kind and selfless :D I only choose Homura because i like her power a bit more ^^;

But Homura got her booty kicked by Mami in Rebellion Story.

Yeah ^^; she also went kinda coockooo ^^; (PS Mami vs Homura epic fight ) :D

Yup. Homura tried to kill Bebe for no good reason!

Homura got (or was ) crazy in Rebellion (i wanna watch the movie with english subs to get it more)

Yup.

Sorry but, Homura was about to win if she didn't gave Mami some rights as a person :P
Ahh.. shi---- no she has a reason, she thought, okay, she thought, Nagisa is a witch. Don't really like kind characters, and I think she is kinda naive :P

I- um... who to pick??

One is kinda crazy
The other one is kinda naive

I mean it, who do I pick up?

Let's see... Homuhomu, in Rebellion, got creepy to me
Umm Madoka, I think I'll go with the friendly one

Madoka is my favorite character after the ending of episode 12. Homura is my 3rd favorite character after the ending of episode 12. Unfortunately, she dropped to the 5th favorite character after 'Rebellion' movie. Madoka is not truly useless and she is not an asshole.