Harry Potter vs Chạng vạng Club
tham gia
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
Obviously, this spot is about debating Harry Potter and Twilight, and I realised I've never written an article, so I decided to put down all my reasons for Harry Potter being better than Twilight.

Firstly, the 'love' in Twilight is not love. It is over powered lust. To my memory, Edwrad and Bella never have a conversation about from who loves the other more. Edward likes Bella because she smells good, Bella likes Edward because he's 'handsome' (which can't even be proven, he's a book character, we never see him).

The tình yêu in Harry Potter is shown as an amazing, all powerful thing that can sace the world. As Dumbledore đã đưa ý kiến "[Love is] a force at once thêm thêm wonderful and thêm terrible than death". tình yêu is everything. It was tình yêu that kept Harry alive all those times. One quote can some up the amount of tình yêu in Harry Potter:

"After all this time?"
"Always"
-Dumbledore and Snape, Chapter 33 of 'The Deathly Hallows'.

Twilight những người hâm mộ often claim that Twilight is better because it is a tình yêu story, but there is romantic tình yêu in Harry Potter, too. Like Ron and Hermione, Harry and Ginny and James and Lily. All cute couples who actually know what tình yêu is.

Harry Potter has types of tình yêu Twilight cannot even dream of, Friendship tình yêu and family love. The one example of family tình yêu in Twilight is Renessmee (sp?). In Harry Potter, family tình yêu is shown everywhere, most predominantly when James and Lily die for Harry. There is also friendship tình yêu in Harry Potter, most notably between the trio. They are willing to die for each other. In Twilight, Bella ditches her Những người bạn when she meets Edward. Bella treats her Những người bạn like rubbish.

The best example of tình yêu in Harry Potter, in my opinion, is the story of Snape and Lily. Snape was in tình yêu with Lily from the time they were children, he did everything for her. But He insulted Lily, calling her 'Mudblood' (a derogatory word for a muggle born), in their fifth year. He still loved her when she hated him, even though he Mất tích her to his worst enemy. He loved her so much, he stopped being a Death Eater and spied on Lord Voldemort for Dumbledore. Eventually, he died for Lily. (I like to think they met in heaven who made up ^^)

The một giây problem with Twilight is how sexist it is. Bella is a weak female who just sits around waiting for her prince to come. Bella never does anything herself, she moans all the time instead. When Edward leaves, she mopes for four months. Four months over a boyfriend she didn't even know that well.

Harry Potter is full to the brim of strong girls. Some examples are:
-Hermione- smart, brave, even when she's bullied she stays strong
-Ginny- Brave, funny, friendly
-Tonks and Lily-die for their families
-Luna- again, constantly picked on, but never changes.

The Harry Potter females made me happier with who I was, but Bella just made me depressed.
Talking of Edward, this brings me onto my tiếp theo point. Edward Cullen is an abusive stalker. He sneaks into her room and watches her sleep BEFORE they were going out. Even if they were going out, it would still be creepy for him to sneak in. As for abusive, Edward takes the engine out of Bella's truck so she can't see her best friend, just because Edward doesn't like him. That's not love, that's outright abuse.

Another reason I don't like Twilight is because of the author, Stephenie Meyer. Compared to J.K Rowling, Meyer looks even worse. To illustrate this point, take a look at their Philanthropy sections on Wikipedia:

Meyer:
link

Rowling:
link

Stephenie Meyer only gave money to help someone she knew who was in need, not out of the goodness of her own heart.

Also, Meyer cannot write. The Twilight 'Saga' is full of short, simple sentences with constant reference to Edwards supposed 'beauty'.

Harry Potter ,on the other hand, is full of complex, interesting sentences full of only relevant information. Even things that don't seem important at the time turn out to be. Most of Meyer's work is pointless information, such as what Bella is wearing.

Another problem with Twilight is the attitude towards deatha nd the perception of war. Meyer seems to be scared of death, even though "to the organised mind, death is the tiếp theo great adventure". In her final battle, no-one dies. This is completely unrealistic! None of the characters have to work for what they want. Not only is this a bad story line, it's unrealistic. bạn also have to work for what bạn want! That's life!

My final point is that Twilight makes no sense. I know the old argument; "It's fantasy, it doesn't have to make sense!". This is true to an extent. But there are too many inaccuracies to ignore.

For a full list, visit the 'Scientific inaccuracies' page on Nữ hoàng băng giá apples(link). I will danh sách the main ones here.

Firstly, bạn cannot gain, lose hoặc change your chromosomes in any way. What bạn are born with, bạn keep. So Meyer saying that bạn gain two when bạn turn into a vmpire is wrong. There is no way around it.

Secondly, if the ma cà rồng keep human sized teeth, there is no way they could drink blood. Human teeth aren't long enough.

The final scientific inaccuracy is the fact that Twilight ma cà rồng sparkle. Meyer says that the venom turns each cell into "a single facet" of a "crystal like substance". If this is true, the ma cà rồng shouldn't be able to di chuyển at all.

There are three thêm things that make no sense in Twilight. Firstly, Bella's family actually believed she had fallen down some stairs and through a window just because she's a little clumsy. Surely if this happened, Doctors would be concerned. bạn can't be that clumsy. There's going to be something wrong with her balance.

Also, Forks isn't the rainiest place in America. And even if it was, clouds don't stop the sunlight reaching the earth.

Finally, Carlisle hid in the sewers of London. Around Carlisle's time in London, sewers were just open ditches in the ground. So either the police were very stupid, hoặc Meyer didn't do her research. (If they were open ditches in the ground, how did sunlight not get in?)

Thanks for reading!
added by lakota_spirit
added by KateKicksAss
added by jodarchy
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
added by lilcherrywine
added by sapherequeen
posted by harrypotterbest
Harry stood at the forest’s edge without moving. He was thinking to leave, when a flurry of movement within caught his attention. Peering at the massive shape he could see, he realized too late that it was a wolf. He jumped out of the way, and the chó sói, sói landed where he had been a một giây before. He looked down at it. The wolf, which had reddish-brown fur, growled up at him. Impulsively Harry withdrew his wand from his jeans pocket.
The chó sói, sói stopped growling when it caught sight of the raised wand. It transformed into a man, and Harry backed up, astonishment on his face. The wolf-man spoke....
continue reading...
Andrew: Okay, well, it's time now for our interview with the one and only, the fantastic, the charming, the bubbly - as Laura and Elysa described her after the hiển thị - interview, Stephenie Meyer. And now, for those of bạn who have read Breaking Dawn hoặc are planning on đọc it, we do get into the plot of the book, but I inserted a little spoiler warning before Breaking Dawn content so you'll know when to stop it so nothing gets spoiled for you. So, we'll take it away to our interview with Stephenie Meyer. Joining us now is Stephenie Meyer, the tác giả of the highly successful Twilight saga,...
continue reading...
"Why compare Harry Potter and Twilight? Why would bạn compare such different things?" are two các câu hỏi this spot has come across often. And to be honest, it irritates the living crap out of me when people ask this.
The media plays a role in things and this thảo luận is no different. On the cover of Breaking Dawn there is a quote from USA Today saying "Move over Harry Potter".(Newsflash, we're not going anywhere) Now, don't tell me that doesn't anger you/ bạn wouldn't feel angry if bạn were a Harry Potter fan. "Stephanie Meyer is the new J.K.Rowling." It really pisses me off when people say this...
continue reading...
posted by TeamSiriusBlack
I did not write this.
1. Bella is a perfect character (“Mary Sue”), which Meyer hides bởi calling her clumsy.

2. Being clumsy is not a flaw if Edward always catches her.
3. She can’t do anything without Edward.
4. And when he leaves she attempts to commit suicide.
5. Meyer is living out her own fantasies bởi nghề viết văn about Bella, who is clearly herself.
6. The sách aren’t well written, just because every other word is a fancy adjective doesn’t make it good writing.
7. All the rules Meyer sets for being a vampire are broken bởi the end of the series.
8. Not only that, she breaks rules set by...
continue reading...
posted by DivyaHarry
These are hình xăm of girls who are over-the-top obsessed about Twilight. Click on the đường dẫn to see them.

link

link

Are these people kidding themselves? The worst is the Edward Cullen/Robert Pattinson one. Ugh!

I was horrified bởi looking at them. It's one thing to be a part of a fad but it's a whole different thing to make that fad a part of your body.

What is the world coming to? Tomorrow when these girls go to get these horrors removed they'll probably be spending a lot thêm than they spent paying to get it done.
Now here's the thing that seems to be the được ưa chuộng topic now. Harry Potter sách and the Twilight series. First I'd like to point out I do not call Twilight a "saga" is because well if bạn look it up bạn will know why. There's this whole big clash of the Twilight fanatics and the Harry Potter fanatics. I just need to vent out on how I feel about this situation.

Okay if bạn tình yêu Twilight than that's fine with me. I respect your opinions, but to me the book was terrible. bạn can instantly tell that it was Meyer's first book she had ever written. I only hate the book, I don't hate bạn for liking...
continue reading...
added by hostaniol
Bella thiên nga is a complex character. On the one hand she emphasizes the need to be independent, on the other she depends on guys to make her life meaningful. The emphasis on Edward and Jacob being handsome are probably the only reason she wants either of them. Her personality never grows over the course of the sách and thus her interesting-ness is never explored. In contrast; she does take responsibility for her actions. Edward being an abusive, manipulative and obsessive boyfriend has been discussed and beaten to death a million times. But these qualities come across as endearing to Bella....
continue reading...
posted by siriuslyawesome
A little play.

(setting-a stage. Creepy smoke rolls on ground, odd blue lighting. Edward stands looking at tường and thinking)
Edward:Hmmm...
Harry:Hey Edward! What's going on?
(Edward ignores him)
Harry:Is something wrong? Is Bella being a pain or...
Bella: (runs in) WHY ARE bạn MAKING EDWARD UPSET?
Harry:I'm not trying to-
(Hermione runs in, panting)
Hermione: I heard yelling-what's going on?
Bella: Harry's making Eddieward mad.
Harry:I just asked if he was okay-
Bella:AND THAT MADE HIM UPSET!
Hermione: Bella, calm down.
Bella: DON"T TELL ME TO CALM DOWN bạn CALM DOWN!!!!!!
Hermione: That's...
continue reading...
posted by Mysticfallstown
Well i think that it's quite obvious that HARRY POTTER has thêm những người hâm mộ than twilight. Cause some people might not of heard of twilight before. I also think that people would like HARRY POTTER better because....

there is thêm action and killing
some people might like wizards better
the weasley brothers are funny

I think people would like TWILIGHT because....

there is thêm love
some people might like ma cà rồng better
it's a great story

I don't have a favourite because i tình yêu HARRY POTTER and i tình yêu TWILIGHT.HARRY POTTER and TWILIGHT are amazing.

By, Mysticfallstown xxx
added by youknowit101
Source: imperfectwords@Tumblr
added by TrueHufflepuff
Source: Whoever draw it
added by Icestorm08
Source: ME!