trả lời câu hỏi này

Harry Potter Câu Hỏi

Is this a mistake hoặc something? Confused. :P

Well, after coming back from watching HP7P2 for the billionth time, I just have ONE question: WHY THE HECK DOES HARRY BREAK THE ELDER WAND? I mean how does he mend his phoenix wand? And who's wand does he use in the future? And why the eff is that scene even there?? :P
 cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
next question »

Harry Potter Các Câu Trả Lời

LadyNottingham said:
They meant it as a dramatic gesture screenwise.

But honestly, they could have made an even thêm dramatic scene, even short. I would have replaced the whole scene on the bridge with Harry snapping the Elder Wand and throwing it away.

This is what I would have done : Harry, Ron and Hermione are back on the island where Dumbledore is buried. Harry mends his old phoenix wand (like in the book) and replaces the Elder Wand in Dumbledore's grave, then repairs the marble slab - that had been destroyed bởi Voldemort to steal the Wand - to niêm phong, con dấu it forever. It would have conveyed the idea that first, he has undone what Voldemort had done at the end of DH1, then that he did not wish to have power. The scene ends with our 3 young Giải cứu thế giới standing together around Dumbledore's grave, but with serene gazes, together, confident that the world will be better off from now on, with a wonderful sunshine in background. It would have been as dramatic screenwise and thêm respectful of the book.

I know, David Yates should have called me for the last scene. LOL
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
that would have been Perfect!! :))
mandali posted hơn một năm qua
*
*votes best answer*
mandali posted hơn một năm qua
*
cool
lilysev1134e posted hơn một năm qua
Aqua_Rose said:
I haven't read the last book, but I've heard about this.
I think its supposed to mean that thats the end of the story, and Voldemort won't be returning. But I'm not sure :S
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
bạn really can't understand the frustration of this scene if bạn haven't read the book. Sorry but thanks for trying to help anyway. :S
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
*
:)
Aqua_Rose posted hơn một năm qua
gry said:
i know... i didn't watch that movie but i read the book. and my friend (who's not a serious người hâm mộ he only watches the movies) started talking ab0out it and i got confused, but i was ADAMANT that the book is right and the movie is wrong. in the end, he gave up trying to tell me, so.. well anyway, bạn know how people change the phim chiếu rạp from the books. like the percy jackson movie, and the narnia movies
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
yeah i guess you're right, but the point is, the movie basically destroyed what những người hâm mộ had it mind and i just thought it was frickin wrong! ah well, watch the movie, bạn wont regret most of it :)
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
*
LOL – Liên minh huyền thoại thx i will :)
gry posted hơn một năm qua
KudoMouri193 said:
Well, that's why I always feel disappointed every time I watch the movies. They don't same like the books!!
And I think, Harry broke the elder wand in the movie to make a dramatic scene (or to prove that Harry isn't hungry of power).
And about what wand he uses in the future, I think movie never explain the detail about something. So, it doesn't matter, because it always like that.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
Thanks! I fee really frustrated as well, I mean for they even cut out the Ravencaw Common Room Scene *le gasp* Haha, anyways, thanks again. :)
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
Danea said:
THANK bạn VERY MUCH!!!!! ----- Well, i guess bạn know how David Yates work...oh well.
The real scene must hiển thị how he mends his wand with the Elder wand.
When I saw this scene I literally laughed out loud in the movie house and I was not the only one who did so. ---
Do the counting- how many times has David Yates made mistakes and Flaws? making the people who didn't read the sách understand the wrong things and subjects. Some scenes are put in just to waste time.
Another HUGE flaw was in Order of the pheonix, about Snape's memory. The people sees James bulling Snape...but where is Lily? And how does people know what happened, that Lily and Snape aren't Những người bạn anymore - Mudlblood- and I don't even want to go on about half-blood prince, -- didn't even put a một phút in of Snape teaching the Dark Arts,,, HELLO! The whole book is titled in his name!
----------------------David Yates----------------
The Main Reason
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
haha, I agree with bạn on so many levels. :) Thanks BTW
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
indiarain said:
because harry potter is unique~!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
^^ sorry, that isn't a good answer :P
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
peppergirl30 said:
Well,he broke the elder wand so no one else get obsessed with the power it contains. But before he breaks it he repears his phoenix wand with the elder wand because it is the wand with the most power ever made. Hope this helps you!
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
yeah I know that, I've read the book but in the movie, it is otherwise. He literally breaks it and doesn't repair his wand. :P Thanks, anyway. :)
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
lilysev1134e said:
Harry mends his first wand with elder wand in the film then breaks it to ensure that no-one else will die over hoặc because of it. he uses his own wand in the future after returning dracos to him. the elf's are really inportant in the film aswell
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
I'm sorry, but bạn made a mistake. In the film Harry DOESN'T mend his wand with the elder wand, in fact he just snaps it and throws away. Plus where did the elf come from? :P
cuteypuffgirl posted hơn một năm qua
*
what elf?? huh confused?/
alisonfaith297 posted hơn một năm qua
*
sorry but i ment book and elfs are in the war i am the im the harry potter champion where i live we have contests
lilysev1134e posted hơn một năm qua
alisonfaith297 said:
to be honest, i think the writers just missed it out. in fact n the entire movie series, they missed quite a few details. the thing is 2 and a half hours is not a lot of time to squeeze of the details so they had to be selective and decided mending it was not such a big deal.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
boolander25 said:
Because the phim chiếu rạp are crap and don't relate to the sách at all.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
jameswilson said:
Yea that's a travesty in the movie that DOES NOT happen in the book.
In the book Harry lays the wand back in Dumbledore's grave where it belongs. Such a better ending, don't know why those fools changed it for the movie.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
mossears133 said:
Read the book, it'll all make sense
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
madeye319 said:
Because it's like being the biggest hoặc best fighter, there's always going to be someone looking to beat you. Harry didn't want hoặc need the power of the elder wand. It had caused nothing but death. The original owner was murdered for it & Harry wanted the cycle to stop. Someone else already basically đã đưa ý kiến that but figured I'd throw my opinion out there. As far as why they changed it from the book, I can only guess that for time & dramatic purpose they changed it. They added stuff in the last movie from the sách that they neglected in other movies, Dobby, Harry's mirror, Bill Weasley
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
eireng said:
Well in the book harry fixes his old wand first with the elder wand .

why they did different in the movie idk but the sách are the real story.

select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
next question »