Harry Potter vs Chạng vạng Club
tham gia
New Post
Explore Fanpop

Alright, I have already dissected one very common fallacy invoked bởi some Twilight những người hâm mộ and a few Harry Potter những người hâm mộ as well, the Edward-fallacy. I shall not discuss that one but instead I will be moving on and examine another common fallacy invoked bởi some fans, using what I believe is the two most common forms of it.


Firstly, let us examine the logical reasoning behind "You are just jealous, therefore your argument is invalid".
It is invoked when any người hâm mộ post an argument and employes this one as rearguard to fend off counter arguments; hoặc it is used as an counter argument alone. In essence, bởi their logic, invoking jealousy immediately dismisses the opponents argument as defeated, and not worthy of any further discussion.

Now, this type of argument is one of the most atrocious fallacies in existence. Instead of counter-arguing against the opponents arguments, it dismisses them bởi attacking the merit of the person who put the original argument forward. The formal name is Argumentum ad hominem (argument to the person - personal attack fallacy), and in my opinion it is one of the vilest fallacies one can commit.

bởi insulting/attacking the opponent in a debate, one immediately loses several vital things, like respect. Further, insulting one's opponent has not moved the thảo luận phía trước, chuyển tiếp as the original arguments remain untouched, and therefore stands until a proper counter-argument takes them down.
In conclusion, calling one's opponent jealous is not helpful at all for one's cause. It firstly removes one's respectfullness; secondly it allows an opponents arguments to stay in place, which is basically handing one's opponents the victory. Now isn't that extremely beneficial for one's cause? Innit?


Secondly, we shall examine the above quote. We pose one important question: Why is this argument false?
Firstly, let us see if there are any connection between these two statements: A persons jealousy and a book series' quality. Then I shall prove to bạn that jealousy is dependant of quality and not the other way around.

The level of jealousy of any person is most often a most personal feeling. It comes when any other person around us possesses something we do not possess, while this something is a thing we desire to have. Then we are jealous.
The quality of any book series of anything is dependent of several things. The grammatical correctness of the prose and therefore the ability to easily navigate the text, the level of interest they raise in us, the difficulty of the words in the prose, the moral message they present, et cetera. Whereas jealousy only touches the quality of a book series if and only if it is already possessing good quality, for who would even be interested in a book for starters if it is riddled with misspellings, faulty sentence order and promotes values we despise? Let alone desire to possess it?

Thus, jealousy is dependent on the quality of a book series, since it appears after the establishment of đã đưa ý kiến quality. Therefore stating that quality is dependent on jealousy is inherently contradictory to the above proven hypothesis. So bởi stating the một giây hypothesis, one is obliged to prove it in its own term to defeat the contradiction.
As of yet, no one has presented me with convincing evidence that quality is dependent of jealousy. Since I compiled proof of my hypothesis (that jealousy is dependent of quality), I hazard to say that it stands.
Therefore, jealousy depends on quality, not the other way around. Quod Erat Demostrandum - Which was to be proven.


To call one's opponents jealous while not counter-arguing đã đưa ý kiến opponents arguments hands đã đưa ý kiến opponents the victory bởi fiat, while being simultaneously fallacious and unworthy of respect. While arguing that "You're jealous of my book series, therefore my book series has quality" is at least a very false argument.
added by youknowit101
Source: moviemistakes.com
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
added by youknowit101
added by Gred_and_Forge
Source: Tumblr
added by zanhar1
added by cassie-1-2-3
Source: http://www.rickey.org
added by mr-cullen
added by RealSunshine
Source: LJ,tumblr,HP những người hâm mộ and Alessia @ FP
added by cassie-1-2-3
Source: http://www.rickey.org
added by Gred_and_Forge
Harry Potter
willy wonka
added by RonGetYourWand
Source: ReasoningWith ma cà rồng
added by xxshannen1xx
added by venvargie
Source: ad on fanpop
added by youknowit101
Source: tumblr
added by expertclassical
added by frankthe2nd
Source: tumblr