link

link

I love both! She's got such a nice-sounding voice.

Emma Watson said the director, Bill Condon, actually tricked her into singing this live because he said for her to sing it live to match up with the lipsync and that he would add the studio version in later. However, he told her later that he was always going to use her live version for this song over the studio version. She really does have a good voice, not great by any means. I honestly never really noticed autotuning in her voice for the studio versions of her songs and still don't. This one just sounds better and more real.

I actually think she sounds the best in this song than any other song in the movie. The other songs she sings in are a lot more autotuned and this one is more natural; I think if she sounded like this in all the songs I'd prefer the soundtrack overall.

^Excuse me, Emmy Rossum? Austin & Ally? Are you the second version of hatelarxene? Sounds pretty similar. No one talks about them here.

Anyway I slightly like her voice in this one, sounds better.

Lmao, I agree with Atomic. Don't forget Zendaya's voice in The Greatest Showman (her voice was good, but it's clearly autotuned in certain parts, which nobody ever points out).
Emma Watson's criticizers just like to pick on Emma because it's Emma, so they mindlessly throw the word "auto-tune" at her.

I remember when people were claiming Dwayne Johnson's voice in Moana was auto-tuned (when it wasn't). Same thing's happening to Emma. Do people even know what auto-tune is?

Lmao there it is

I'm 50/50 on this and AtomicWedgieBoy and hatelarxene, no hard feelings, but I think both of you need to stop this controversial topics.

@hatelarxene & AtomicWedgieBoy:
Ok, I try to stay away from petty disputes on here now, but whatever;

1) Are you two the same person? If not, you're clearly soulmates and should get married. I'll be waiting for my wedding invitation.
2) I have adored Emma Watson since the first Harry Potter movie and have defended her so much over the years, so forgive me while I scoff and laugh at your ridiculous "hater" comments which were clearly directed at me. Evidently no one else is a wise autotune expert like you two, but regardless of autotune her voice in the other songs sounds more robotic, at least to me. As clearly implied from my original comment I like her voice in this specific song, so again not a "hater", just an objective unbiased opinion.
3) I find it hilarious how you act like you're so superior in your comments on this site when in reality you just can't accept anyone having a different opinion to you. People would be more likely to respect your opinions if you didn't act like a whiny piss baby whenever someone says something you don't agree with. If you want to label people haters just to make yourself feel better then that's up to you, but my advice would be to grow up.

I don’t remember her singing this at all? Maybe I blacked out during this scene? Anyway, this one sounds best.

they are equally bad imo. But this is slightly better