There are some scenes and quotes from the book that im disappointed they left out, and some things in the film aren't in order with the book but overall im happy with it, its an adaptation, we can't expect it to be as perfect as the book, they've kept a lot more stuff and stayed truer to the novel than most book-movie transfers do!

: )

You know i Don't feel ashamed! Umm.... thought it was good. When i go to watch it, Im going to pretend i never read the book...

The new scene that came out in the rome film festavial, I never thought that the scene was going to be like that EVEN when i was reading the script. But i think that some of the scenes are going be way too awkward, but i hope that can pull it off. I hope it's good. I hope people like it and i hope people don't get like too mad, because OMG you know that there are like some fans that like are REALLY true to the book!

I can't wait ;)

^^ I totally agree about the scenes being awkward.
Like when she calls him a peeping tom... she never calls him that! That'll be the time when I look over at my friends and say like... "umm I have to go to the bathroom". Hahahaha.
And he doesn't use the key he jumps in the window!!!

Oh and sorry if I'm typing slow. I'm on my phone cuz I'm at school and I should be paying attention :D
But I'm not.

HaHa love that the reply! =D! 1treehillfan

^^ Thanks i also really hate the hotel scene... awkward. no wonder rob really doesn't like edward or the books.

Yeah it is really akward...

=)

definitely

it was good, but theres so much i love about the book that wasnt there ;\ she never said that he dazzles people ?! :( plus emmetts like barely in it and i lovee emmett ! they just cant capture twilight in 109 pages

Love ur comment kelsey887 =)

the begining was my favorite part out of the whole thing. there are major changes but at least it sticks sorta close to the story line. Im just pissed they make james in most of the movie, it seems like there just trying to amp you up for the nomads when really the story isnt really about them its about the battle for forbidden love. and im mad that edward doesnt kiss bella when they split up to distract james. in the book they kiss and bella describes it almost as if it were a last kiss. The kind you get when you might not see that person again. Im sure the movie will be great im just afraid it wont be great enough

and isnt the reason rob hates edward in the books is because he read midnight sun?

people expect SO much from the movie. they are SO many stages. like, there are people who want to see it really bad and thinks itss gonna be really good, then people who dont know, and people who arent gonna see it. there are so many people who've read the script, and Im thinking that their opinion of the script changed the way they viewed the movie. i hope people who've read the script didn't change their mind about seeing the movie... sigh.. that would be terrible. :(

It was very different but I like it. I am just going to try to not make any comparisons between the book and the movie when I see it because that is what ruins most of the adaptations for me and I really want to love this movie! :D

i don't feel ashamed either. i mean, it's not like i didn't know what was going to happen anyway...
overall, i thought it was alright

I read it, but only the dialogue parts. I was a little disappointed. But then I started seeing all the trailers and it totally re-excited me about seeing the movie!!!!