did charlie die in breaking dawn

No have bạn read the book.....??

He totally did. It was really graphic but he got into a fight with Bella, right? And she was like "I'll get Jacob to kill you." And he was all "No bạn won't." Well, lets say that she did. Jacob ended up ripping all of Charlie's limbs off one bởi one. Then, he just let him bleed to death. It was awesome.

Did that help?

No... it would have been a little bad if he did. I would have started crying like I always do when someone dies in a book hoặc movie. I cry even if they are side characters. I even cried when Harry Clearwater died for christ's sake!!!! And he was barely mentioned!!!!!

no

No,of course not!Where'd u hear that?

Nooo..... Where'd bạn come up with that idea??

Um no. How'd ya come up with that idea?