Editors React: Did The Walking Dead go too far in 'Twice As Far'?
Spoiler Alert: The following discusses plot points from Sunday night\'s
Editor at Large Aaron Sagers and Contributing Editor Tara Bennett give their reactions to this episode written by Matt Negrete, and directed by Alrick Riley
Aaron: After we dissolve through a few pre-credits scenes of the daily routine in Alexandria, post-Savior showdown from last episode, we head off on the co-existing storylines that see weaker members of the Safe-Zone attempting to be proactive. As the story cross-cuts between Denise and Eugene, I was thinking, at first,
was going to deliver a very important message about the value of the less-physically-inclined survivors, aka the brains.
But no. I half expected Denise to die horribly from how much attention she was being given in this episode, but still convinced myself she was safe (because I’ve been really enjoying what Merritt Weaver has been doing with this character). So when she got an arrow to the head -- which was intended for another character in the comics -- I was genuinely surprised.
Let me be clear: I think it was a terrible decision to kill Denise. Her relationship with Tara added diversity to this show, and she’s been an excellent example of a woman who can survive and bring something to this team, despite not being a warrior. But, as far as eliciting a response from me, and keeping me on my toes, the show succeeded.
Tara: I\'m with you on the surprise of Denise\'s murder, but I firmly put that entire scenario in the Lowlight category (see that subhead for more of reaction). As for what I did enjoy this week, I like the technique of the repeated montage at the start of the episode to establish what life is like for the Alexandria citizens weeks after the Savior encounter. There\'s a bucolic vibe that the "rinse, repeat" with slight variations scenario portrays effectively. Patterns and expectations are allowed to take root in the new Safe-Zone society and it\'s important for the audience to get that, and it\'s done in an interesting way.
Aside from that, I was struck by how much Carol\'s arc has profoundly moved me. After the gut-wrenching realizations last week for Carol (seeing so much of who she\'s become reflected back at her in Paula (Alicia Witt) and not liking it
), this episode plays her ensuing remorse, guilt and soul-searching so subtle as to almost miss it. That is, until the devastating end. It starts when she asks Daryl about letting the guy who took his bike go. You can see in that moment how much Carol counts on knowing that Daryl will always make the right moral call. So when he tells her that he should have killed him, that\'s the moment she understands this world is ruining everyone she loves, and what\'s left of the person she still wants to be deep inside. If she can\'t rely on the fact that Daryl is still open to doing the right and moral thing, then what\'s the use of living with these people, who have become her family, anymore? Because it\'s only a matter of time before they all become a cold husk like Paula, or Molly, and maybe even Rick at this point. Watching all of that play out in Melissa McBride\'s face in this scene, and as she helps Daryl bury Denise in the last minutes was the kind of acting married with character exploration that gets into your head and doesn\'t let go. I\'ve been deeply thinking about Carol\'s entire arc since the fade to black on this episode and that\'s when you\'re reminded that television, genre or not, can sometimes truly transcend.
Aaron: Another interesting highlight for me is that we’re right around issue #98 of the comics. In that title, I recall the insanity surrounding fandom when a crossbow showed up, and people thought Robert Kirkman might be introducing Daryl Dixon to the comic-verse. But nope, it was only Dwight. So it worked for me that Dwight returns now -- after stealing Daryl’s crossbow in last November’s “Always Accountable.” The now-scarred member of the Saviors is back, and we witness the show dovetailing with the comic.
What’s more, Daryl’s act of mercy is indirectly responsible for Denise’s death. After the bit of foreshadowing where Daryl finds Dwight’s woodcarving, Carol complimented/admonished Daryl that being a good guy was just in his nature. But will he now transform into a killing machine?
Tara: In some ways, hasn\'t he already? What he and Rick and some of the others have done to "protect" the family makes them no better than the Saviors, so I\'m still desperately hoping Carol\'s leave is a tipping point moment for them all. It\'s a moral exploration I want to see not presented as a weakness, but as a basic need to save humanity. Deanna wasn\'t wrong to try to keep her citizens moral. She was wrong in sheltering and babying them, but there has to be some common decency retained. I am deeply interested in knowing what moral balance is going to be restored despite as Carol says, "the next threat to take what I have."
Aaron: There\'s also Eugene. Josh McDermitt keeps adding depth to this oft-comedic character. I miss the mullet, but I’m pleased the show allowed him to adapt and survive -- and that his bromance breakup with Abraham is not permanent.
Aaron: So, the Denise death. She finally takes out a walker; finds the soda Tara has been mentioning in her sleep; opens up about her love for Tara; offers an inspiring speech about the strength, resiliency, and sincere goodness about Daryl (with whom she had a budding friendship I never quite bought) and Rosita; demonstrates her own inner strength about her ability to psychologically survive in this messed up world. Then, an arrow through the head.
just killed off one of its lesbian characters after her big moment. It was cruel and ill-timed. Is the message this series is sending that only the physically adept can survive? Denise had value as a character, and yes, I am invested enough to miss her – and maybe that means the show did something right – but it strikes me as unnecessary and cruel. And cheap, quite honestly.
Tara: Sadly in 2016, this is a trope that is still grievously being over-used. Another current major genre series (title omitted for spoilers) just did this to the show\'s only lesbian couple and it\'s not ok. If we lived in a world where there was complete parity in heterosexual and homosexual relationships in film and television, we could argue that writer\'s have the freedom to explore any death that will directly impact another character\'s ongoing arc. But we don\'t live in that world. Healthy LGBT relationships portrayed over a length of time in television are still in the minority, so when you portray a strong one and then subsequently wipe it out, it says something very negative to everyone watching, intended or not. And no, it doesn\'t mean that the lesbians are equal in experiencing loss like the heterosexuals. Denise and Tara have already experienced plenty of loss. Why make them suffer more when wiping out beloved characters is just about a weekly occurrence now? Why not keep them together on the show to illustrate what their love can achieve in a post-apocalyptic world that needs as much love as possible to show it
worth living? It\'s a tremendous waste of fresh, original storytelling on the series, and for what Merritt Weaver and Alanna Masters could have done with that storyline.
Aaron: Another lowlight was the departure of Carol. Since this wasn’t really a Carol episode, her exit lacked impact. She had a moment with Daryl before the credits – and it was great seeing these two chat, if for a few scant seconds – but then she’s gone.
I recognize Carol has been experiencing a crisis of faith lately. She had become an efficient, calculated killer, and the pendulum has recently shifted into her being more hesitant about taking life. In the last few episodes, she\'s wanted to reclaim her moral center after tallying up the number of human lives lost at her hands. That story arc could, and should, have continued. Put her in a situation where she has to protect Daryl, or against the odds with just Morgan at her side, and then test her resolve and morality.
Dear Tobin and Alexandria departure fell flat. Abrupt. Additionally, I\'m left wondering if she is gone for good this time. If Carol disappears, only to unexpectedly pop up later, it will be a repeat of her earlier re-appearance. If she stays gone, it will be an unsatisfying exit for one of the show\'s strongest characters. I expect we will see her again, but worry about the series re-treading familiar ground.
And the entire presence of Morgan building his cell (because “It’ll give us some choices next time”) was a forced piece of groundwork-laying. He could have been entirely excised from the ep.
Tara: One, we don\'t know if Carol\'s storyline is done. With two more episodes left this season, I\'m not going to assume that, and as I stated above, I felt her reason for leaving and how she chose to do it completely worked for me. To clarify, I\'m not in the least bit happy IF this is the end of her story in the series. McBride\'s Carol is the standout arc of the entire show and losing her as an actress and what she brings to the dynamic is irreplaceable. If her permanent absence proves to be the case, how she chose to exit does make sense at least. This has been percolating since Morgan basically entered to burst their bubble of moral superiority when it comes to their violent actions. Actually, it\'s been coming since her conversation with Tyreese in "The Grove" and her choice regarding Lizzie. If you have a soul and a conscience, there is a price to bear for the horrible deeds done. Carol has been trying to justify it all inside her head for a long time and she knows in this situation, on this path, she\'s can\'t do it anymore. She\'s not dead. She\'s survived by herself before and I find a lot of comfort in knowing she, of all of them, could do it again.
As for Morgan, I read it as Carol judge him very hard for his moral compass, and she\'s come to her own decision that he\'s been right (to an extent) all along. Of any of them inside those walls, Morgan is the only one of them that can live with his actions to date. He may have regret about other people\'s violent choices but
choice to not take a life is one that allows him to retain his soul. He\'s seen Carol\'s internal torment and I\'m interested in if he will try to find her despite her request to be left alone.
Aaron: Again, this has to be Denise’s death. Such a bummer. It was a shocker, even if I don’t think it was good storytelling.
Tara: Carol leaving was my shocker. Despite my getting it, I didn\'t see it coming. With Denise, she was basically doing Sam Jackson\'s
rant when she got murdered and we all know the characters on the peripheral who get center stage might as well be wearing a red shirt.
Aaron: I\'ll add Eugene’s failure to dispatch the tin-man walker was a nice visual component to the episode, but I really felt the mother/child walker combo in the apothecary. I saw a version of this coming (though I wondered if they’d pull a
zom-baby), but it was nonetheless pretty wrenching. Also, excellent visuals of that “hush” mom walker.
Tara: There was some smart technique this week and Carol\'s decision was the most earned emotional moment of the season. But Denise\'s killing again has me asking if I\'m seeing a reason to want to survive in this world when there\'s less and less hope to hold onto. Watching weekly walker butcherings and massacres aren\'t why I tune in, it might be for many others, but not for me.
Aaron: Although there were elements I appreciated in the episode, I’m going to call this week a fail for me. People die in this show, and I have come to expect it. But the dispatch of Denise was second to Glenn’s fakeout demise in terms of this series’ more egregious offenses. She died for no reason. And who the hell is going to be the doctor now?
Daredevil Season 2, Episode 1: The Man Without Fear is back, but with a bang or a whimper?
Contributor Editors Tara Bennett and Mike Avila return to Hell\'s Kitchen and breakdown new Season 2 episodes every two days.
There are times when Superman can plausibly kill someone, but
Daredevil vs. Season 2: A spoiler-filled take on Matt Murdock's return and The Punisher's debut
The wait is finally over, and the eagerly-anticipated second season of Marvel\'s
Fear the Walking Dead producer on hitting the high seas in Season 2, crossover potential
Batman v Superman: Dawn of JusticeThe JokerThe RiddlerZack Snyder
The Joker and the Riddler were almost the villains in Batman v Superman
That Ghostbusters spinoff from the Russo brothers has been scrapped
The Maze RunnerDylan O'BrienWes BallThe Maze Runner: The Death Cure
Maze Runner star seriously injured in set accident
Guillermo del Toro's next project is a supernatural drama set during the Cold War
Tune up for the epic tussle and listen to the entire Batman v Superman score right now!
Jurassic Park, Crystal Skull writer signs on to script Spielberg's Indiana Jones 5
How Earth's magnetic field saved the planet from being fried billions of years ago
Who Won the Week, Episode 17: Daredevil Season 2, Indiana Jones 5, X-Men: Apocalypse
Hunt demons with Wynonna Earp in new footage from Syfy's supernatural series
The Flash's Andrew Kreisberg opens up about how Barry Allen will fit into Supergirl
Syfy expands 3D printing partnership with MakerBot for 12 Monkeys, Hunters
Marvel Comics reveals Team Iron Man and Team Captain Marvel for Civil War II
The new footage in this extended Warcraft TV spot will give you all the LOTR feels
To Hell's Kitchen and back: Charlie Cox on Daredevil, Season 2, Elektra, The Punisher – and Bullseye?
Simon Pegg beams aboard Steven Spielberg’s Ready Player One
Disney taking another shot at Chronicles of Prydain, after 1980s failure of Black Cauldron
Amber Heard is playing Mera in Justice League and Aquaman, here's what she had to say
Iron ManMarvelAnthony RussoJoe RussoCaptain America: Civil War
Civil War director Joe Russo on how he thinks the next Iron Man should be introduced
Past Issues: 19 classic comic books that may have been in Merrick Garland’s collection
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.Clark GreggCaptain America: Civil WarChloe BennetInterviews
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. cast promise fans a messy end for Season 3
10 of the greatest superhero vs. superhero battles in comics history
Captain America: Civil War helmers on the Spidey suit: 'there is still effects work that needs to be done'
Scientists have recovered fossils from a pregnant T. Rex, DNA could be next
The Highlander 30th Anniversary: There can be only one video about the immortal classic
Radar scans confirm secret chamber in King Tut's tomb, hidden for millennia
It's official: Marvel and Netflix confirm Finn Jones as Iron Fist and reveal a new character
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justiceben affleckDCZack Snyder
Bruce Wayne and Alfred talk superhuman threats in new Batman v Superman clip
The Legend of TarzanAlexander SkarsgardMargot RobbieSamuel L. JacksonDavid YatesWarner Bros.movie Trailers
New official trailer for The Legend of Tarzan reveals the Lord of the Apes' origin story
A dragon lands, and an Onion Knight appears, at Game of Thrones event in NYC
Back to the Future fans! Nike unveils the first self-lacing shoes you can actually buy
J.J. Abrams opens up about what's taking so long with HBO's Westworld
Sally Field kicks her Aunt May and The Amazing Spider-Man to the curb
Batman v Superman's Henry Cavill went incognito in Times Square to prove glasses really are a good disguise
President Obama honors Marvel's Sana Amanat, co-creator of Kamala Khan, at the White House
X-Men: ApocalypseJames McAvoyjennifer lawrenceMichael FassbenderOscar Isaac20th Century Foxmovie Trailers
Let's go to war with this new explosive trailer for X-Men: Apocalypse
Preacher showrunner on bringing the comic to TV: 'Tone is the hardest part'
Get in the ring: 9 horror and sci-fi monster showdowns to remember
Deadpool VFX breakdown takes you through that exhilarating highway chase scene