he made so many mistakes in season 5 and other seasons to and nathans made some mistakes id they are pretty even but i figured everyone would vote nathan so i said lucas

luke's made his fare share of mistakes, but nate's screwed up more in s1 than luke has in all 5 seasons combined. I think ppl forget just how much of a creep nate was in s1 till he and haley got serious. the list runs long of nate's screwups throughout the seasons. Nate isn't a bad guy, but I think luke's mistakes hit fans harder cause they have to do with the love triangles between our fav characters (brucas/leyton/lundsey)...

nates had a lot ... but the things nathans done havnt pissed me off like the things lukes done! lukes a dickface! at least nate owns up to his mistakes and makes things better(point shaving)- luke doesnt even care - e.g -
. BLP - he didnt have any consideration for brooke
.saying ihy to peyt - he didnt even think she would care (how does he not fall down more with being this dumb)
. kissing peyt and then proposing to manface - i mean manface doesnt even know yet!
. there more but i cba naming them! haha :]

At least Nates mistakes can be put down to having Dan and Deb as parents Lucas has no excuse but that he's a born ass.

***how does he not fall down more with being this dumb***

laurra, you crack me up :D

Nathan has mad heaps of mistakes!

:D ... isnt that off friends - im sure i didnt come up with it on my own! - its off one of the shows i watch for sure!

lucas has emotionally screwed over so many people and continues to thoughout the show. nathan has messed up a bunch as well but he has made fewer and fewer as the shows gone on. i think that lucas has finally caught up to nathans problems.

Nathan made many minor mistakes but Lucas has screwed up BIG time plenty.

ya i agree with 1treehillfan.....lucas 1.) cheated on brooke 2.) slept with nikki 3.) got engaged to lindsey (EERRRGGG) 4.) cheated on brooke with her own best friend and lead Peyton on when he got engaged to lindsey the same night!