Haley used to be cute, now in season 5 she is really beautiful.. But Peyton is much prettier :)

I think "Hot" is more then looks it's also attitude. Haley's confidence and kindness makes her hott, besides the fact that she is pretty.

Mkay, Haley will never compare.

LMAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
haley is the exact opposite of hot .
peyton is STUNNING!

haley is prettier but peyton is hotter

does that make sense lmao

Peyton is way prettier, I think the only competition for Haley on the show is Mouth (the cast is hot, they're not really :P).

Peyton is so cute! Brooke and Peyton both. Ok not to offend but Haley looks freakishly just like this man at my work. I think "she" use to be "he" if you catch me drift ;)

in my opinion Haley is not pretty, while Peyton is stunning!

HALEY IS NOT PRETTIER THAN PEYTON, I JUST FELL OFF MY CHAIR READING THAT! OMFG LEYTON4EVER I LOVE YOU BUT YOU`RE SERIOUSLY BLIND!

Completely agree with Elliesowner you have to have confidence in urself and Peyton most of the time doesnt seem to have it..