Nathan is older than Haley. They đã đưa ý kiến several times that Haley was a năm ahead of every one else in school & she graduated at 17, while everyone else was 18. Then in season 5 she talks about being 21 & everyone else at that time is 22.
posted hơn một năm qua
this is wrong. she is not a yeear ahead of everyone else because then that would make her a năm older, think about it.
and they were both 16 when the got married, and haley wasn't 17 when they graduated, bạn don't know that. brooke is the only one of the five that we KNOW turned 18, cause of her birthday, but we assume everyone else does. and in season five the therapist tells them they are both 22 năm olds and they should live a little
exactly, like, she graduated early. in episode 5x4 she is sitting on the đàn piano bench with peyton and she says that she is 21 years old, and since that is 4 years later, that means that she graduated at 17,
NO SHE IS NOT RIGHT! they both got married at 16! THINK ABOUT IT PROPERLY! isay nathan's birthday is in march, then he would be 18 at graduation. but haley's birthday might be in august, meaning she would only be 17 when she graduated, but they are in the same year. again, when she is sitting on the piano, it might be before her birthday this year. and i'll say once more, when they go to the therapist, [after 5x4 when she says she is 21] they ARE BOTH 22 YEARS OLD! face it, you're wrong.
i think the yr. changed dependin when they did it, because each năm they made it into 2 seasons. so when they decided what năm each person was born relative to the episode air date. so then we just change it. and also haley prob was just born the end of the năm to make her the youngest. because if she nd luke have been best Những người bạn since they were 8 hoặc 9 (in s1 karen tells tht to keith) then they wld most likely be in the same grade. and they are both married at 16. most of the năm im lets say 15 while my friend is 14 but we are born in the same year. just depends on the month.
well we know that karen was preg lik in june b4 dan left so luke is feb. so nate is like april. nd so if there is an epi that we kno haley was still 17 when they grad. nd then in 5x04 haley is still 21, which means haley was prob born @ the end of the yr. because there is no way haley skipped a grade, because haley nd luke have been best Những người bạn since lik they were 8 so tht is 2nd hoặc 3rd grade. and since we know tht in the endish of s5 both nate & haley were 22, haley is prob born @ the end of the yr. i wld say maybe oct - dec.
from wiki: According to Wikipedia:
Lucas was born on March 1988. Nathan was born on June 1988. Peyton was born on July 12, 1988. Brooke was born on March 4, 1989. Haley was born in 1989.
i know brooke is known from 4x02 her birth certificate and peyton from her gravestone from 4x10
the rest not sure how they figured it out. it doesnt make tht much sense to me to have brooke and haley be a năm younger....
posted hơn một năm qua
According to wikipedia: link, Haley is born in 1988, so that makes her the same age as everybody else
I THINK its Nathan, but they never really talk about birthdays hoặc ages. I do recall that in season 5 Haley đã đưa ý kiến she was 21, and I think Nathan had đã đưa ý kiến he was 22, but I don't know for sure.
okay. i thot it was actually đã đưa ý kiến sumwhere tht she was a yr. younger. the way i c it. is she didnt skip a grade but shes just born @ the very end of the yr.
i actually did think about that but realized that the tiếp theo school năm started before that episode, which would have been at least 3 months past their graduation. but it doesn't matter anyways because they changed their ages now anyways. they had to make nathan & haley 23 so they could do the seven-year itch episode.
I always thought it was Haley who was older. =/ How can be Nathan a năm older than Haley? I don't remember them saying that. And they both got married with 16 years old.
