cuz Peter, though powerful, is far too nice. Sylar...well.... yeah.

^^ thats exactly what i thought when i was making this pick. sylar wouldnt be afraid to kill, peter would be like ohh lets just not kill them ;)

Peter's so hot! And he could beat sylar if he really wanted to

But I think Peter's niceness would help in a fight. He would always be loyal, I wouldn't put it past Sylar to kill someone from our side!
Plus,Sylar is very quick on swapping sides!!

sylar might switch sides

any day, Sylar is the ultimate hero! And yes, i do count him as a hero rather than a villain, he is so misunderstood poor thing, he wants to do right!

Sylar might kill me afterwards just for the heck of it!
Peter, on the other hand, I can just show him how grateful I am...;]

So this is hard.... on the one hand, Pete is more powerful but on the other hand Sylar is better at using his power to it's full extent. BUT Sylar is likely to kill me anyway where as Pete will not.....

That is such a tough question but I just go weak for Sylar, so yeh.

I definitly wouldnt want to be against him! At least Peter might be compassionate and let me live