It was a hard choice for me between Remus and Sirius. :D

Sirius is too reckless and at times, idiotic (telling Snape that Remus is a werewolf), Peter's a traitor although I do pity him considering James' and Sirius' treatment of him shown in Snape's Memory and James is a bit too arrogant. Remus is, IMO, the more sensible and empathetic one and a very strong character, considering what he's been through.

I'm surprised no one's picked James yet.

I don't think I know enough about James to pick him. This was a difficult choice between Sirius and Lupin, they have different personalities, and are lovable in different ways. Lupin is very kind and empathetic and Sirius is fun and adventurous.

James is cool but serios is awesome. why would you vote for wormtail?

Read too many fan fics about James/Lily, but still, Sirius tops them all...

Followed obscenely closely by Lupin. Don't know enough about James to love him, and, well, the only way I could love Peter is if I loved to hate him (which I don't, I just find him annoying).

I had to pick Remus. He has the most sense and stayed alive longest.
But Sirius is soooooo great, how could I choose

hands down sirius

super sweetheart i love him but in the 5th movie he is so not hott and in the book it says he is hott

u gotta love james i mean COME ON but i love serious too

Lupin - because I'm a Tonks girl at heart!

Sirius and James remind me of Harry and Ron. Sirius has a lot of the same qualities as Ron and... well... I adore Ron so by that logic...

I actually cant stand the way they portrayed james potter in the films. hes mint in the books but in the films hes bald and looks 40 when he was 21 when he died. i mean COME ON!

i love both lupin and sirius

my fave hp character

You made me choose between Padfoot and Moony D:!! You evil person!! I love them both so much!! But... Lupin takes more insult from people than Sirius does, and i think i prefer Sirius's attitude.

Remus is my second fav after Tonks.

sirius and lupin!!!!!!!! definitely NOT wormtail lol

but i really love lupin tooo!!!!

I love Lupin's modesty!=)

I kinda started to dislike Sirius when he was acting pathetic and spoiled in OOTP, but then he died and I cried like an idiot...

I like Remus better, he's just... well... adorable :)

Wormtail was a traitor, Remus kept whining about him being a werewolf and 'betrayed Tonks', and Sirius and James were dicks to Snape and Kreacher. So that would leave me with choosing 'none of the above'...

moony forever

Sirius and Lupin.

Gahh that's just too hard. I love them all, not Pettigrew though

Hard realy hard to choose

James/Prongs because he's great a loveable and he was Harry's father.

i still don't understand how Wormtail was ever their friend...

But I like all THREE of them. I'm not counting the traitor! :)

i love lupin love him im a wear wolf at heart now hes asome and so strong even if hes a wearwolf but still has a family love him

I was just wondering... why nobody picked Wormtail... ;)

I love Sirius

i love james and sirius............they r both soooooooo cool!!!!!

Closely followed by Remus. James is a bit of a douchebag and Peter is a weak, slimy git who doesn't deserve to be called a marauder.

Siriussssssssssssss <3 <3 <3

i also like sirius :)

Definitely Padfoot though it was a hard choice between him and Moony :D Remus is a close 2nd fave.

Sirius anyday!

Nawwww i love Moony <3

Best Hogwarts teacher ever.

Closely followed by Remus. Sirius is my favorite character in the books, and Remus is definitely somewhere at the top of the list.

I'm happy that everyone that chose on this pick had some sense and didn't choose Peter... lol.

I absolutely love him. Sirius is alright and the rest are losers, but Remus is number one.

remus is close though i HATE james aand wormtail w a passion

And Lupin

and sirius

Remus = awesome.

Sirius Or Remus:)

My absolute favourite :P

and my second favourite is Remus/Moony

He seemed really cool as a kid :) a little bit of an idiot, but cool and then Sirius and Lupin are tied, of course Wormtail just ruined everything so no surprises he has no picks ;)

Sirius and Remus are the best :) Then James of course.

As much as I love Moony and Prongs, Padfoot is number 1.

No one with common sense will pick Wormy :p

I think Lupin or Sirius