trả lời câu hỏi này

Harry Potter vs Chạng vạng Câu Hỏi

What was your least yêu thích book to movie inconsistancy?

All the phim chiếu rạp changed things from the books. What was your least yêu thích inconsistancies in each series, and which scene, one from each series, did bạn want them to add, but they didn't?
 goodtimes posted hơn một năm qua
next question »

Harry Potter vs Chạng vạng Các Câu Trả Lời

cassie-1-2-3 said:
Harry Potter inconsistency:
I suppose it's in the fourth one. I was looking phía trước, chuyển tiếp to the maze scene, but the movie made it boring. The hedges were normal static hedges that didn't do anything, and nothing really happened, like in the book.

Twilight inconsistency:
Eclipse, the scene where they're rolling around in the bed. In the book, Edward đã đưa ý kiến he didn't want to go further because he was protecting his own virtue. He wanted to stay a virgin. In the movie, they made it into a macho thing "I want to keep bạn a proper virgin bride, Bella". That really bothered me.

HP missing scene:
I would have liked the potions scene in the first one. The scene where Harry had to drink the correct potion to get to fluffy.

T missing scene:
I kind of wanted to see the scen at the beginning of BD where Bella was driving the tên lửa proof car and got caught talking to the two guys.
I get why they cut it, it wasn't relevant to anything, but I wanted to see it.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
HP Missing scene: He had to drink the correct potion to get to the stone. He just needed to play âm nhạc to put Fluffy to sleep. Sorry it was going to bug me.
simpleplan posted hơn một năm qua
*
What? I was referring to Snape's logic challenge where they were được trao a danh sách of clues and had to figure out which potion to drink.
cassie-1-2-3 posted hơn một năm qua
*
I agree about both of the missing scenes, and definitely about the maze in HP 4.
KateKicksAss posted hơn một năm qua
VampiresRevenge said:
Harry Potter:
inconsistency: The deaths in DH: Part 2 that didn't happen in the book, and Mundungus not being introduced until DH: Part 1.
add: All of the memories of Tom Riddle in HBP.

Twilight:
Since I've only seen Twilight and none of the other phim chiếu rạp yet (I know, bad fan), I wish that Victoria, James, and Laurent had thêm screen-time since I remember them being in the book quite a bit. And I don't really remember any inconsistencies in the first movie, which means I should probably watch it again, haha.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
zanhar1 said:
Bellatrix was left out a lot. And her death scene; disgraceful to Bellatrix, Helena, and her fans.

As for Twilight I honestly don't care for the phim chiếu rạp they are worse then the books. I think the sách are better in many ways.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
i have to say though, bellatrix i felt was just right in my opinion, the death that did not justice was tonks, lupin and fred.
alisonfaith297 posted hơn một năm qua
*
bạn kidding me!? Herdeath was horrible I was expecting a longermore dramatic battle and the Bellatrix falling to the floor, seeing her lifeless body which would've made me sadder as it should have! Tonks ad Lupin's sucked too. All of the deaths in that movie sucked exert Snape's.
zanhar1 posted hơn một năm qua
*
David Yates is a moron
snusnu13 posted hơn một năm qua
bri-marie said:
Harry Potter
Inconsistencies: The burning of the Burrow in HPB; cutting out the memories in HPB; making Harry just stand there under the stairs in HPB; the hospital scene in OotP; the final fight in DH2.
Missing Scene(s): The confrontation between Snape and Moody. Not for any necessary reasons. That was the only part of book four that I liked. Plus it would have được trao Alan Rickman thêm screen time, which is always a plus.
Tonks/Lupin and Bill/Fleur...anything. They were just suddenly together without any indication that that was going to happen. Bill wasn't even introduced before the seventh movie.

Twilight
Inconsistencies: I can't think of any major ones, and it's been too long since I've read hoặc seen the phim chiếu rạp that I can't remember any little ones.
Missing Scenes: I do wish we'd seen the snarkniness between Rosalie and Jacob in BDpt1. Again, not out of necessity. That was a really funny part, and Rosalie's character has sadly been in the dark the past few movies.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
omg! yes the memories in HBP!
alisonfaith297 posted hơn một năm qua
*
the snarkiness between Jacob and Rosalie make me kinda ship them together, actually...
ClaireVoyant posted hơn một năm qua
cuteypuffgirl said:
Harry Potter:
I was really angry at how Bellatrix and Voldemort's death was portrayed in the movies. (Exploding into confetti, really?) Then I was not a big người hâm mộ of the Burrow burning in HBP and then then I really hated how Fred was shown as a ngẫu nhiên dead guy with no explanation of how he died whatsoever (that guy deserved a death scene!) Then we NO TEDDY!! I WAS SO MAD AT THE FACT THAT TEDDY WAS CUT OUT! XP I could on and on.

Missing scene: The Ravenclaw common room scene, I really had that scene perfectly visualized in my head in the book but was angry when they cut out that scene in the book and replaced it with some Kickass Luna dialogue.

Twilight: (I havent read all of the sách in its finality except for the first so I'm basing my opinions on the first movie alone, I attempted New Moon but only made it as far as the third chapter before dropping it.)

I was not happy how Charlie was portrayed to tell bạn the truth, he was like a stand in almost with no real purpose at all... I was not happy with how some scenes were pointless, (we don't care about how Bella makes dinner!!)

Missing scene: Even the phim chiếu rạp suck thêm then books, I thought the first book was pretty decently converted on screen. No complaints there.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
*
Bella didn't make bữa tối, bữa ăn tối in the movie.
cassie-1-2-3 posted hơn một năm qua
*
Ikr how dare they explode Bellatrix!?
zanhar1 posted hơn một năm qua
*
Disney death that is.... it does looks silly
ClaireVoyant posted hơn một năm qua
theelderwand said:
In Harry Potter:
Cutting Dobby-GOF, OTP, HBP
The burning of the Burrow-HBP
Only hiển thị 2 memories-HPB
Not hiển thị Fred's Death-DHP2
Mcgonagle not leading desks into battle-DHP2
House-elves, Centaurs and reinforcements attacking deatheaters-DHP2
In Twilight:
The way the Wearwolves(shapeshifters) were visulised-NM onward.
The rest I was OK with.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
alexisn10 said:
Harry Potter:
--In the Deathly Hallows book, Harry and Dudley have a very touching scene that puts me in tears. They cut it out in the movie as well as the Harry and cây dạ yên thảo, petunia scene (I don't remember if that was in the book).
--Cutting out the scene when Draco saves Harry in Deathly Hallows Part 2.
--Ginny, in general. I honestly hate movie Ginny. She just stands there. When Fred dies she just stands there all while the rest of her family is crying their eyes out. I tình yêu Bonnie Wright but I really hate Ginny.
--Cutting out Dobby from Goblet, Order, Half Blood (was he in Half Blood I don't remember)

Twilight:
--Bella. In general. I tình yêu Kristen Stewart but movie Bella, just like movie Ginny, sucks. Book Bella (even though I don't like her either) is a drama queen. Movie Bella is Drama-LESS!
--Rosalie's scene in Eclipse. They should have added how she longed for a baby and kind of used Bella to get it in Breaking Dawn.
--Cutting out Bella's school friends. In the phim chiếu rạp they were just awkward people with, like, 5 lines.
--Kiss in Twilight. He didn't go to her giường and have half-sex with her lol. Their Kiss was like 8 giây and then Bella started freaking out. I liked their first Kiss in the book.
--Jacob and Bella's Kiss (in Eclipse). I felt nothing. There was no chemistry between them...
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
TheBreeze said:
Harry Potter-
I really wanted to see the Ravenclaw common room. I don't know why. And Winky. And Bagman. Ugh, there's so much.

Twilight-
I wish they'd done thêm of Jacob. I don't know why, but I always felt he didn't get enough. Also, the way the Người sói talked. I hated that.
select as best answer
posted hơn một năm qua 
next question »