the movie practically changed the story line now i wonder what they'll do for eldest, hated the movie they ruined the story line. they even killed off characters who are in the second book
I saw the movie first and loved it so much I got the books straight afterward!
I think the book was a lot more descriptive - which is a winner for me as I have a vivid imaginaton.
After reading the book, the movie seemed very rushed. However, I did like the movie too.
no wayy, the book is better.
the movie was totally not the book! galbatorix wasn't even s'pposed to show up yet!but oh well, i guess if you saw the movie first you would like it, but still the book is wayy better to me.
don't vote if you haven't read the book... I mean seriously, there is no literal comparison. The movie sucked in practically every aspect... except for Murtagh... he was hot
ANYONE WHO PICKS THE MOVIE OVER THE BOOK, YOU ARE NOT A TRUE FAN AND I SAY TO THEE IN THE ANCIENT LANGUAGE, "Eldrvarya unin brisingr eom anglat!"
If you want to know what that means go to:
link
thats where im learning the ancient language! ;)
Besides, the movie sucked
Avatar-is-life-
YOU SPEAK THE TRUTH. You and me are TRUE Eragon fans because we choose the book! And...I also say this to you who chose the book!
"MAY YOU SUFFER 'DU NAMAR AURBODA'!
i never liked the film that much due to its short running time it didnt give the characters enough time to develop and missed major story plots and ruined any chance of a sequel that is why i prefer the book
If you pick the movie, you are NOT a true eragon fan, and should not be on this website!!! The movie killed off charcaters that werent ment to, killed characters in DIFFERENT ways, changed scens, turned DWARVES into HUMANS... the only thing right they got was their names...
They cut out all my favourite parts and more than half the story! Everything was messed up! They can't POSSIBLY make a second movie now because there are too many major plot-holes.
i'm pleased to see that most of the eragon fans didn't like the movie..i agree it sucked.they didn't follow the book,they didn't pay enough attention to the really important parts of the story and it was a low-quality movie..no wonder why the saga won't be featured
the only people who chose the movie r those who havent read the book. read it, c how completely s**t the film is & then you'll want 2 change ur pick.
the book is a million times better than that completely crap production they called Eragon
loved the book and yes the movie did leave a lot out :( but instead of using our imaginations we can look at beautiful Garrett being the best character,Murtagh!!! =)
garrettsgurl is right about Garrett *drool*, and I watch it again and again just because of him.......but i had to pick book.....the movie is only watchable becuz of garrett hedlund and jeremy irons........and if you havent read the book....its not a bad movie..
The movie was a huge mistake! I was very badly dissapointed!
The only good thing about it was the cast (I mainly mean Garret Hedlung and Jeremy Iron.
While the book is amazing!
I thought Arya was supposed to have black hair, and nobody nows how Galbatorix looks. Maybe he has like long blond hair and looks like he is just twenty years. So its stupid to show Galbatorix in the first movie.
The book was awesome!!!
And if you compared the movie to the book- it's a load of crap.
There is no way anyone who read the book would prefer the movie.
se ono waise neiat ilia! to the director witch is may you be not happy in the anchiant language you disgraced the book barzul i curse you with ill fate in dwarvish and if i could find more in this book i would
I think the book was a lot more descriptive - which is a winner for me as I have a vivid imaginaton.
After reading the book, the movie seemed very rushed. However, I did like the movie too.
the movie was totally not the book! galbatorix wasn't even s'pposed to show up yet!but oh well, i guess if you saw the movie first you would like it, but still the book is wayy better to me.
I Agree completely...
But the books were wonderful.
If you want to know what that means go to:
link
thats where im learning the ancient language! ;)
Besides, the movie sucked
YOU SPEAK THE TRUTH. You and me are TRUE Eragon fans because we choose the book! And...I also say this to you who chose the book!
"MAY YOU SUFFER 'DU NAMAR AURBODA'!
the book is a million times better than that completely crap production they called Eragon
The only good thing about it was the cast (I mainly mean Garret Hedlung and Jeremy Iron.
While the book is amazing!
i loved the cast, though, in the movie (i think garret hedlung did the best!!!!)
<3
And if you compared the movie to the book- it's a load of crap.
There is no way anyone who read the book would prefer the movie.
đăng nhập hoặc tham gia fanpop để đăng bình luận của bạn