do u think it was right when edward gave bella a braclet after seeing jacob gave bella a braclet????

I think it is right, 'cause he wants to give her a present since her birthday (new moon).

I think it's right. In the book he says that it was his mother's and that Esme and Alice have one just like it. So yeah i think it was right.

he shouldnt have được trao bella the bracelet cuz he knew she liked it and he made it look like he was richer than jacob cuz it was a diamond thingy!

Edward didnt give Bella a bracelet.... he gave her a diamond charm to put on the bracelet that Jacob gave her...the chó sói, sói represents Jacob and the diamond tim, trái tim represents Edward...I think it was inconsiderate for Bella to easily accept presents from Jacob but not from Edward her soulmate and I think it was inconsiderate for Jacob to give another guys girlfriend jewelry ..he would have been really upset had he been the boyfriend and someone was giving his girlfriend jewelry.

Team Twilight.

I thought is was really nice Edward gave Bella the braclet. Bella is always telling Edward that she doesn't want his gifts because she already has him, it's about time she accepts a gift from Edward. Edward totally had the right to give it to her if Jacob has a representation so should Edward!!!<3 TEAM EDWARD ALL THE WAY :P

Well it was the same braclet just a charm and it has both of what she loves he wants to know he has a place in her tim, trái tim bu tit was rude because it was jacobs gift

Yes, I think he's right.

in the book it meanched that jacob gave her a handmade and hand-me-down bracelet and charm and Edward đã đưa ý kiến "i want to be represented" and the tim, trái tim was his mother's so basiclly he wanted to be reprensented as one of her những người đang yêu which i think is sweet so it wasn't inconsiderate

edward didn't really give bella a bracelet he just gave her her a dimond charm to put on the bracelet. any way i think he has every right 2 give her that charm cause she loves him thêm and chose him, plus she is his wife so i would say he had thêm of a right to give her that charm

yeah it was bellas birthday anyway