No contest, i loved Jessica Bowman much more as Collen. Erika was good, but Jessica was more relatable and warm...plus she got Andrew!!

Totally agree ;)

I hate when show's do that and think you won't notice. Hello they went from a blonde to a brunette. That is the only thing that really annoyed me about the show. Jessica did a great job but I still liked Erika better.

i likes Erika better!! the blonde colleen is the real colleen for me, she was the first and i kinda got stuck for her.

Erika was definately more believable than Jessica...blond hair, better acting, more expressions, sweet spirited. Jessica's acting was very basic.

i prefered jessica as colleen because she is more caring and not a crying little girl like erika plus she married her crush and went on to become dr colleen cooper-cook she and brandon douglas(andrew ) are a better match in my opinion

I liked Jessica better, but I would have loved the show just as much had Colleen not been replaced on the show--that does annoy me

I liked jessica better than erika. When she acted she seemed so real and erika seemed so fake. Jessica is such a better actress

Erika was a much better actress. it really annoyed me when they chaged the actress especially since they replaced her with a brunette...i mean couldn't they have at least tried to get someone who looked similar?? I eventually got used to jessica being Colleen tho.

Jessica just didn't do it for me most of the time. Erika was far better. She was so much more talented than Jessica would ever be and then there was this natural chemistry between Erika and Jane, Sean and Chad. In Jessica's case it always looked like *acting* and that's what annoyed me. Of course, she had her moments too, like in "Cooper vs. Quinn".

I didn't like the change in Colleen's character after Jessica Bowman took over. Colleen seemed to lose her confidence in herself and was too easily influenced by other people. She seemed to have lost her backbone!

Jessica is a horrible actress and to homely look to fit in erika's shoes as collen

Yes very annoying when they switch actors no reason why? ?? Loved erica

Jessica Bowman, I felt like she was more mature and I liked her together with Andrew

I like Erika Flores far more than Jessica Bowman. The latter doesn't seem as real and belonging to the family as Erika. It's a pity that she left.

Jessica, I felt that she fitted in more!